Chapter 61: Father Perez, the Girl in the Mirror, and Annabelle at the Church Door
Danny had been waiting on this lead for weeks.
He filed the leave request before he'd finished reading Ed Warren's message, then checked the train schedule. Next departure south toward Fairfield County wasn't until early afternoon. He could have made better time under his own power, but the distance didn't justify it and he'd learned to take the ordinary option when the ordinary option existed. There would be nothing ordinary about where he was headed.
He said goodbye to Jennifer at the school gate, which took longer than expected because Jennifer had opinions about the frequency of his disappearances, most of which were fair. He listened, agreed where she was right, kissed her, and left.
He made it approximately half a block before someone stepped out of the alley mouth ahead of him and blocked the sidewalk.
"Maria." He stopped. "Shouldn't you be in first period?"
The girl looking back at him was wearing Maria's face and Maria's clothes, but the posture was completely different — weight forward, chin up, the particular quality of someone occupying a body with full confidence rather than apologizing for taking up space.
"I skipped," she said. Direct eye contact. No fidgeting.
Danny waited.
"I want you to break up with Jennifer," she said. "And go out with me instead."
Danny looked at her for a moment. Then he took two steps closer — not toward her, exactly, more in the direction of the conversation — and crouched slightly to put himself at eye level.
"If Maria actually wants to say something to me," he said, "she should say it herself. Does she need someone else to do it for her?"
A beat of silence. The confidence in the posture flickered.
"How did you know?"
"Yesterday you couldn't maintain eye contact for three seconds," Danny said. "Today you're propositioning me in an alley. The jump is a little steep." He straightened up. "Who are you?"
She took a step back. Reassessing. "Alan."
"From the mirror."
The reassessment deepened. "You saw that."
"I notice things. It's a professional habit." Danny studied her — the way she was running Maria's expressions like someone driving an unfamiliar vehicle, competent but not quite natural. "What's the actual plan here? Aside from the pitch."
Alan's composure settled back into place, harder-edged than before. "Maria wants you. Maria won't do anything about it because Maria won't do anything about anything. So I handle it."
"By doing what, exactly?"
She didn't answer that directly, which told Danny the answer involved options Maria wouldn't have sanctioned. He filed it.
"Here's what I need you to understand," he said, and snapped his fingers.
The alley didn't change physically. But the quality of the air did — the temperature dropped three degrees and the shadows deepened in ways that shadows didn't normally deepen at nine in the morning, and standing beside Danny, visible in her full manifestation, was Mary Shaw.
Not the contained version. The projection. The image of what was inside the card, made present enough to be perceived by something like Alan.
Alan went very still.
Danny let her look for a few seconds. Long enough to be instructive.
"I work with things significantly more dangerous than a mirror personality," he said, without any particular emphasis. "I don't say that to threaten you. I say it so you have accurate information." He put the projection away. "Don't hurt anyone at school. Don't do anything that would put Maria in a situation she can't walk back from. And if Maria actually wants to talk to me, tell her she can do it herself — I'm not difficult to find."
He picked up his bag.
"I have a train to catch."
He left Alan standing in the alley with the expression of someone who had expected this to go differently and was now recalibrating everything from the beginning.
Connecticut.
St. Anthony's Hospital, Fairfield County.
Father Perez occupied a room on the third floor and looked like a man who had been through something that his entire framework for understanding the world had not prepared him for. Which was accurate.
Ed and Lorraine Warren were already there when Danny arrived, seated in the chairs beside the bed with the particular manner of people who had been in hospital rooms under these circumstances before and knew how to be present without being intrusive.
Ed stood when Danny came in, hand extended.
"Danny. Good to see you in one piece. We heard you were running down the Mary Shaw situation."
"It's handled," Danny said. "More or less."
Ed raised an eyebrow — more or less was doing some work in that sentence — but didn't push. If Danny had come back from Raven's Fair ambulatory and apparently intact, that was further than the Church's previous efforts had gotten, and Ed was too experienced to interrogate a result that was better than expected.
Danny looked through the observation window at Father Perez.
"Tell me about Annabelle."
Ed walked him through it methodically, the way he always did — chronological, specific, no editorializing until the facts were complete.
John Form had given the doll to his fiancée Mia as a gift. Vintage Raggedy Ann, the kind of thing you found at an estate sale, unremarkable in every visible way. That same night, a pair of cult members had broken into the building — a murder-suicide, the woman dying while holding the doll. Whatever had been following that woman found the doll a more suitable residence than the body it had been using.
Mia was pregnant. The harassment began almost immediately after — movement, sounds, the particular escalation pattern that Lorraine had documented across dozens of similar cases. The Forms contacted Father Perez, who gave them the standard pastoral guidance: faith, prayer, Scripture. God's protection over a believing household.
That night, Mia was attacked directly. Not the ambient harassment of objects moving or sounds in the walls — a physical assault, demonic manifestation, the kind of thing that left marks.
Perez came himself the second time. He took the doll.
He made it to the front steps of his own church before something hit him hard enough to put him in this hospital room for a week. The doll was gone when the paramedics arrived.
Danny absorbed all of this. Then he said: "It went back to them."
Lorraine nodded. "It always goes back. The demon has chosen its target. Until it gets what it wants, it won't release them."
"What does it want?"
"A soul offered willingly," Lorraine said. "That's the requirement. Demonic entities can't simply take — there has to be consent, even if that consent is extracted through sustained torment. They push until the person breaks and gives in voluntarily."
Danny thought about that structure. The same logic as a con game, essentially — the mark had to choose it, even if the choice was manufactured. Free will as both the obstacle and the mechanism.
"The Forms are still in their house?"
"They moved," Ed said. "New apartment, different county. It found them inside a week."
"Of course it did." Danny looked back through the window at Perez, who was awake now and staring at the ceiling with the expression of a man revising his theology in real time. "What's the Vatican's timeline on reinforcement?"
Ed and Lorraine exchanged a glance. "Indefinite," Ed said. "There are three other active cases on the priority list ahead of this one. The diocese is stretched."
Danny understood the subtext. That was why Ed had reached out to him directly rather than waiting for the official channel to move.
"You want to go to the apartment now," Danny said.
"We want to assess the situation," Lorraine said, which meant yes.
Danny looked at Father Perez one more time. The priest had survived, which was more than could be said for some of the people who'd tried to stand between Annabelle and her target. But survival and effectiveness weren't the same thing, and whatever Perez had tried hadn't slowed the demon down measurably.
Danny had Mary Shaw on a containment card in his jacket pocket. He had Diana, the Wendigo, the wings. He had six weeks of experience working adjacent to the Warrens and a working understanding of how demonic possession cases escalated.
He also had no illusions about Annabelle being a standard case. The entity using that doll had been building power for months and had already demonstrated it was willing to go after clergy directly at the threshold of consecrated ground.
"All right," he said. "Let's go take a look."
[500 PS unlocks 1 Extra Chapter]
[10 Reviews unlock 1 Extra Chapter]
Thanks for reading—reviews are appreciated.
P1treon Soulforger has 20+advance chapters