Bruckner, Chief Engineer of the Naval Technical Committee, adjusted his spectacles with the deliberate displeasure of a man preparing to explain why someone else's ambitions were impossible. He rose stiffly and cleared his throat, his manner carrying the authority of old textbooks and even older convictions.
"Your Highness, I must emphasize that although research into oil-fired boilers and steam turbines has begun, it has yet to produce anything we can confidently employ in a capital ship. Our fleet relies upon coal-fired boilers and proven triple-expansion engines. To abandon those systems for machinery we do not adequately understand would be to gamble with the future of the Navy."
To Oskar, the argument sounded painfully familiar: if something was new, it was dangerous; if it was unfamiliar, it was probably wrong.
He glanced down at Tanya's notebook, found the passage he needed, and answered calmly.
"Your Excellency, refusing to consider turbines will not prevent other countries from developing them. The British are already testing them successfully in large ships. Their results demonstrate the advantages over triple-expansion engines. The question is not whether we will eventually adopt turbines, but when."
He looked up.
"If Britain is already ahead, delaying our own work will only widen the gap."
Several engineers shifted in their chairs. They disliked being corrected by someone so young, particularly when his answer was difficult to dismiss without addressing the substance of it.
Before Bruckner could respond, the Crown Prince spoke.
"Little brother," Wilhelm began, his voice smooth and cold, "oil-fired boilers require oil. Considerable quantities of it, presumably. The Empire does not possess an abundant domestic supply. What happens when war interrupts our imports? Your magnificent ships become floating coffins. Coal, on the other hand, suits our national circumstances. Coal is reliable."
A few committee members nodded, some with genuine agreement and others with the caution appropriate to a statement made by the heir to the throne.
Oskar recognized the challenge, but it was one he had already discussed with Tirpitz. For once, he did not have to search desperately for an answer.
"Your Royal Highness, we can accumulate substantial reserves of heavy fuel oil before a war begins. Storing and handling an equivalent reserve of coal would be far less efficient. Oil takes less space, provides more energy, and allows us to build faster ships."
He closed the notebook, keeping a finger between the pages.
"And the purpose of those ships is to break the British blockade. Once we accomplish that, our supply routes reopen."
He delivered the answer with a certainty that left little room for interruption.
Prince Heinrich raised an eyebrow in approval. Tirpitz gave a small nod. Whatever doubts remained about the design, Oskar was no longer behaving like the confused fifth prince who had described the Naval Academy as garbage. He was defending a proposal before senior officers and holding his ground.
Tirpitz turned toward Heinrich.
"Your Highness, what is your impression of the ship?"
Heinrich stroked his beard, studying the drawing rather than the men waiting for his answer.
"An outstanding proposal," he said. "If the fleet possessed a vessel capable of delivering these specifications, it would represent a considerable improvement in our strength."
The endorsement carried weight. Heinrich was not merely considering how the ship might look in a construction report; he was imagining what it could accomplish under his command.
He turned toward Tirpitz.
"Can the technical difficulties be overcome?"
"There will be obstacles," the Admiral acknowledged. "But I see no reason to regard them as insurmountable. With sufficient resources, proper direction, and the necessary pressure, the shipyards and Krupp should be capable of finding solutions."
Heinrich inclined his head.
"Then the committee must decide whether we are prepared to pursue them."
Count von Warren straightened.
"Are there any remaining questions before we consider our conclusion?"
Brigadier General Gussard raised a hand.
"One final matter concerning the main battery, Your Highness. You specify 305-millimeter guns, but our existing weapons of that caliber are outdated. Their rate of fire, accuracy, and overall performance are inferior to the Krupp 280-millimeter, 45-caliber gun. Would it not be wiser to employ the superior weapon already available to us?"
This time, Oskar did not consult his notes.
"The Krupp gun is an excellent weapon," he replied, "but its shells do not provide the armor penetration we will require against increasingly well-protected British ships. The British already employ 305-millimeter guns extensively."
He paused, then added with unfortunate certainty, "Their next design will carry 343-millimeter guns."
A startled murmur passed around the table.
Even Wilhelm's expression changed. This was no longer a general argument about future developments. Oskar had supplied a specific figure for a foreign design that none of them had mentioned.
Before anyone could question its source, he continued.
"If we remain satisfied with 280-millimeter guns, we risk allowing the gap to grow. Krupp can develop a modern 305-millimeter weapon. We need range and penetration, not merely the comfort of using something familiar."
For a moment, the committee remained silent.
Wilhelm noticed the change in their attention and felt his unease sharpen. Every question seemed to give Oskar another opportunity to sound knowledgeable. Even objections that should have exposed his inexperience had instead encouraged Tirpitz and Heinrich to take him more seriously.
If this continued, the committee might actually approve the proposal.
The Crown Prince rose.
"Gentlemen, Prince Oskar has answered your principal questions, and time is advancing. I suggest we now hear the committee's conclusions."
His smile remained courteous. The interruption was anything but.
Dietrich exchanged a glance with Bruckner before speaking.
"Your Highness has presented an ambitious concept. Nevertheless, too much of it depends upon assumptions that have not been demonstrated in practice. Boldness is not a substitute for evidence."
Bruckner nodded.
"The proposal introduces several unfamiliar technologies simultaneously. Machinery, fuel systems, turret arrangements—each presents substantial uncertainty. Combining them in a single capital ship would expose the Navy to an unacceptable degree of risk."
Dawson added his agreement. Even Gussard, who had shown genuine interest in Oskar's answer about the triple turrets, declined to support approval of the design as a whole.
Their objections came clothed in the language of caution and professional responsibility. Beneath them lay considerations none cared to state openly. Accepting the proposal meant allowing a young prince with little formal training to overturn assumptions upon which they had built their careers. It meant admitting that the future might have arrived at their door without first seeking their advice.
Count von Warren folded his hands on the table.
"Your Highness, your ideas may prove valuable in time. But our duty is to proceed with care, not to commit the fleet to an undertaking whose essential features remain untested. Battleships are too expensive, too important, and too difficult to replace for us to take such risks."
He paused.
"The committee therefore cannot approve your proposal at this time."
Wilhelm's satisfaction appeared before he could disguise it. He turned toward Oskar with an expression intended to convey brotherly sympathy.
"Do not be discouraged. You are young, Oskar. There will be other opportunities."
Oskar said nothing.
He had understood the verdict perfectly. He had also understood the look on his brother's face: the pleasure of a man who had placed a foot in someone's path and was now offering condolences for the fall.
Schadenfreude.
For once, he knew exactly which German word applied.
In another life, he might have overturned the table. He had certainly thrown controllers over disappointments far less significant than this one.
Now he stood still and breathed.
The desire to do something violent remained unpleasantly vivid. He imagined taking Wilhelm by the collar, lifting him out of his chair, and throwing him into a snowbank. A lake might also serve. There was probably some satisfactory arrangement involving both.
He kept his hands at his sides.
Do not rage. Do not lunge. Think.
So much for spiritual progress. Apparently, he still had some distance to travel.
He had known that Wilhelm was jealous. He had known that his brother regarded another prince's success as a personal inconvenience. What he had underestimated was the satisfaction Wilhelm could take in obstructing him when the consequences extended far beyond a family argument.
There was no affection in that expression. Wilhelm did not see a brother trying to accomplish something useful. He saw competition.
For one ugly instant, the possibility of a riding accident crossed Oskar's mind. He dismissed it almost immediately. Plotting against the heir to the throne would turn an already dangerous rivalry into a catastrophe.
Besides, destroying Wilhelm was not what he had come here to accomplish.
He wanted to keep Germany from being ruined. He wanted to prevent the war if he could, shorten it if he could not, and give people something better than the future he remembered. His factories were supposed to make workers safer and help mothers keep their children alive. His ships were supposed to make the country strong enough to survive.
Somewhere beyond all of that, he wanted an ordinary life—ordinary by the standards of an extremely wealthy prince—with Tanya, Karl, Luise, Mister Ice Bear, and an expanding empire of useful things that included a frankly unreasonable number of diapers.
None of those ambitions required the committee's affection.
The thought steadied him.
He had expected resistance, perhaps even rejection. What had shaken him was the ease with which professional caution and personal vanity had become indistinguishable.
No wonder Germany lost, he thought bitterly. Half these fossils would rather sink with tradition than admit there might be another way to stay afloat.
He lifted his head.
"I understand the committee's decision," he said. "But I fear you will soon discover how mistaken you are."
Several men stiffened.
"Your decision will leave the German Navy behind Britain again. And if Germany loses the next war because its fleet cannot keep the sea open, you will bear responsibility."
The silence became absolute.
Oskar continued, his anger forcing him to choose each word carefully.
"When the blockade closes around us, when our trade is strangled and our people begin to starve, what explanation will you offer? Will you tell them that at least every decision followed accepted practice?"
Dietrich's face darkened. Bruckner stared at him, while Dawson's eye twitched.
The accusation had struck every man at the table.
"Your Highness!" Dietrich rose so abruptly that his chair scraped across the floor. "Your birth does not entitle you to insult us. We serve the Empire, not the impatience of an inexperienced child."
His voice filled the room.
"Battleships are not toys. They require careful design, proven methods, and an understanding that cannot be acquired merely by writing ambitious figures on a drawing. With respect, Your Highness, you should be studying at the Naval Academy, not lecturing men who have devoted their lives to this work."
A few quiet laughs came from the back of the room.
Oskar's jaw tightened.
"Enough," von Warren ordered, striking the table with his palm. "We may disagree without abandoning proper conduct."
The reprimand was nominally directed at everyone. The chairman's cold gaze left little doubt about whom he considered responsible.
Wilhelm saw his opportunity.
"Oskar, apologize," he said. "You cannot address Imperial experts in this manner simply because they have rejected your proposal. These men are pillars of the Navy. You owe them the dignity expected of your position."
The righteousness in his voice was almost unbearable.
Oskar could imagine the account his brother would carry back to their father: the foolish prince had presented an impractical design, insulted experienced officers, and lost his temper when they refused to indulge him. Irrational, arrogant, impossible to manage.
It was precisely the outcome Wilhelm wanted.
Oskar raised his chin.
"I refuse."
For a moment, the Crown Prince appeared not to understand.
"Excuse me?"
"I will not apologize for believing that this decision is wrong. I stand by my design."
Wilhelm reddened.
"You insolent—" He stopped himself, but the effort was visible. "I will report this to Father immediately."
A quiet chuckle escaped Heinrich. Tirpitz lowered his gaze, the smallest movement at the edge of his beard suggesting that he was concealing an expression of his own.
The committee had no such difficulty displaying its displeasure. Whatever room had existed for reconsideration was closing rapidly. Having been challenged before the Crown Prince and the Navy's senior officers, none of them wished to appear intimidated into changing his opinion.
Oskar looked along the table and understood that further argument would accomplish nothing.
Fortunately, argument was no longer his only option.
"You are mistaken about one thing," he said quietly. "My design does not need your approval."
That drew their attention.
"This is not a ship I have asked the Navy to pay for. It is my project, my investment, and my promised gift."
He rested one hand beside the blueprint.
"You may refuse to support it. You cannot persuade me to abandon it."
Dietrich's mouth tightened.
"I will build the battleship with my own money," Oskar continued. "If necessary, I will establish the shipyards myself. And when it is afloat—when you can judge its guns, its protection, and its speed rather than dismiss the drawing—you will understand the mistake you made today."
He straightened.
"Money speaks rather clearly, gentlemen. Especially when someone is prepared to spend it."
For several moments, nobody answered.
Dietrich opened his mouth, then closed it again. Bruckner looked as though he had swallowed something unpleasant. Dawson found a sudden reason to examine the ceiling, while von Warren's expression shifted by the smallest degree.
They had rejected a proposal presented for their consideration. They had not quite anticipated that its author might possess both the means and the determination to proceed without their endorsement.
Heinrich laughed openly.
"Bold indeed! Money has made you fearless, Oskar. You are becoming a menace."
Tirpitz did not join the laughter, but his interest was unmistakable. The committee had withheld its approval; the prince had answered by offering to assume the expense and pursue the work himself.
Whatever difficulties remained, the project was not dead.
Wilhelm understood that at once.
He had expected rejection to send Oskar back to his room, embarrassed and stripped of his newfound confidence. Instead, his brother was standing before the committee declaring that its refusal would merely change how he proceeded.
The fortune that had once seemed an irritating indulgence was becoming something far more troublesome. It gave Oskar choices that his brothers could not easily remove.
He could no longer be contained simply by being told no.
Oskar felt the same realization settle inside him, although it brought determination rather than alarm. He would need engineers, factories, machinery, and people prepared to test his ideas instead of dismissing them. There would be difficulties he had not anticipated, and money alone would not answer all of them.
But he had money, a design, and a reason to continue.
That was more than he had possessed a few months earlier.
He slipped Tanya's notebook into his pocket with particular care, gathered his drawings, and turned from the table. There was no final appeal and no attempt to soften what he had said.
His boots sounded against the floor as he crossed the room, each measured step carrying him farther from the place where he had expected to secure permission.
He did not look back.
Behind him, the committee remained seated in a silence thick with outrage and uncertainty. They had spent the morning preparing to dismiss a foolish young prince. Now they had to consider the possibility that he might build the ship anyway.
At the far end of the table, Heinrich watched him leave with a lingering smile.
"Interesting," he murmured. "Very interesting."
Titles alone did not impress him. Results did, as did the willingness to act when other men found reasons to remain where they were.
Oskar had yet to prove that his battleship could fulfill its promises. But he had demonstrated something that afternoon which Heinrich had not expected from the strange fifth prince: rejection had sharpened his purpose rather than broken it.
Heinrich leaned back, brushing his fingers through his beard as the footsteps faded beyond the doors.
The boy might yet become the storm that drove the German Empire into a new age, whether the men around this table were ready for it or not.
