Cherreads

Chapter 21 - Chapter 21: The first debate

As the room settled after Oskar's introduction, Crown Prince Wilhelm spoke, drawing every eye toward him.

"Gentlemen," he began with a perfectly courteous smile, "His Majesty has other matters requiring his attention, so I shall represent him at this conference. I am here only to observe and listen, and I will report your conclusions faithfully."

He paused before extending a hand toward the assembled committee.

"You are among the finest naval minds in the German Empire. I trust that you will exercise the judgment and wisdom upon which our fleet depends."

His manner was gracious, his words carefully chosen. Beneath that polished exterior, however, Wilhelm hoped for only one outcome.

Let these old fools reject the design.

Oskar's growing fortune was already troublesome. If his younger brother also demonstrated a talent for naval engineering, his standing within the Empire would rise considerably. Wealth had given him independence; the Navy's gratitude might give him political influence.

Wilhelm had no intention of welcoming either development. Weak brothers were safe brothers, and Oskar was becoming increasingly difficult to dismiss.

Tirpitz rose before the Crown Prince had quite finished settling into his chair.

"Gentlemen, the Imperial Navy continues to advance, but we remain far behind the British," he said firmly. "We cannot afford costly mistakes, nor can we afford to cling to familiar ideas merely because they are familiar. Prince Oskar's proposal must receive a thorough and impartial examination. I expect neither carelessness nor prejudice to interfere with that responsibility."

Several committee members stiffened. The warning was unmistakable: whatever they thought of the prince, they were expected to take his work seriously.

Count von Warren cleared his throat.

"Then we shall proceed. His Royal Highness and Admiral Tirpitz have made the importance of this evaluation quite clear."

He turned toward the presentation table.

"Prince Oskar, the committee is ready to hear your proposal."

Oskar cleared his throat rather more deliberately than necessary and opened Tanya's notebook. He had spent the morning repeating her carefully arranged sentences until they had begun following him through every other thought. Now he could only hope that the words remained where he had left them.

He stepped behind the lectern while attendants secured the large blueprint against the wall behind him.

A quiet rustling passed through the room, then stopped.

Several men leaned forward. One opened his mouth as though preparing to speak, only to reconsider. Whatever shortcomings they expected to find, the drawing was not the careless collection of guns and armor that some had anticipated.

The hull was long and lean, with a clean superstructure and three triple turrets positioned forward, amidships, and aft. The protection was concentrated around the ship's vital spaces, while the machinery notes described an arrangement substantially different from anything in the Navy's existing construction program.

Even the most skeptical members of the committee found themselves studying it closely.

Oskar drew a steady breath and lowered his eyes to the notebook.

"Distinguished gentlemen, the proposed battleship has a length of 145 meters, a beam of 24 meters, and a draft of 8.6 meters. Standard displacement is 18,500 tons, increasing to 20,500 tons at full load."

He paused, allowing himself time to locate the next line rather than risk improvising.

"Twelve heavy-oil-fired boilers will supply three steam turbines, producing a combined output of 25,000 horsepower and driving three shafts. The intended maximum speed is twenty-one knots. Estimated range is twelve thousand nautical miles at ten knots, or three thousand nautical miles at twenty knots."

A few eyes moved from the drawing to the prince.

"The main armament consists of three triple turrets mounting 305-millimeter, 45-caliber guns," he continued. "The main belt, turret faces, and conning tower will each have 305 millimeters of armor. Deck protection will be forty-five millimeters."

He finished without stumbling and looked up.

For several moments, nobody spoke. Even the Crown Prince's expression betrayed surprise before he brought it under control.

Taken at face value, the specifications described a ship more formidable than any German battleship currently under construction. Its combination of heavy guns, substantial protection, and speed promised considerably more than another improvement upon an established class.

Whether those figures could be achieved was another question. Nevertheless, the committee members exchanged uneasy glances. If the proposal proved workable, it would cast an uncomfortable light upon ships to which some of them had devoted years.

Count von Warren broke the silence.

"Gentlemen, you may put your questions to His Highness."

Sir Dietrich, Director-General of Naval Shipbuilding, rose immediately.

"Your Highness, your design is exceptional on paper," he said smoothly, placing just enough emphasis on the qualification to make his position clear. "I would, however, appreciate an explanation of some of the principles behind it."

Oskar inclined his head.

"Of course, Your Excellency."

"Why have you removed the secondary main battery? Instead, you concentrate the armament in triple-mounted heavy turrets. This is a considerable departure from accepted practice."

Oskar glanced at the notebook. They had anticipated that question, and finding the answer waiting on the page steadied him.

"I believe long-range engagements will become increasingly common," he replied. "At distances exceeding ten kilometers, the secondary main guns will contribute comparatively little. The principal requirement will be to concentrate effective fire against the enemy at that range."

He lifted his eyes toward Dietrich.

"A uniform heavy battery allows us to devote more of the ship's weight and protected space to weapons capable of doing that. Retaining a second main battery adds weight and complexity without providing an equivalent advantage in the kind of battle for which this ship is intended."

His delivery was measured and clear, bearing little resemblance to the confused speech described in court gossip.

Dietrich hesitated. He had expected enthusiasm where an argument ought to be, perhaps followed by an appeal to royal authority. Instead, the prince had presented a position he could dispute but not simply dismiss.

"A novel argument," he conceded. "It remains unproven, however. We must exercise caution before abandoning established practice on the strength of an expectation."

Oskar nodded without attempting to turn the exchange into a victory.

Gussard, the committee's naval weapons specialist, was the next to rise. He examined the turret arrangement once more before addressing the prince.

"Your Highness, no navy presently employs triple turrets. Such mountings would be extremely heavy, with potentially serious consequences for the ship's stability. There is also the question of interference between the guns. Firing all three simultaneously could produce substantial blast effects and impair accuracy."

Oskar turned a page in his notebook. This question, too, was among those he had prepared for.

"Your Excellency, triple turrets allow us to carry more guns without requiring as many separate mountings. That reduces the hull length devoted to the main battery and allows us to concentrate protection around a shorter armored citadel."

He paused before continuing.

"The interference between guns is a genuine problem. But they do not have to fire at precisely the same instant. The two outer guns can fire together, followed by the center gun half a second later. Staggering the discharge addresses the interference without abandoning the triple mounting."

Gussard's expression changed.

He looked back at the drawing, considering the arrangement again. The prince had neither denied the difficulty nor attempted to conceal it beneath assurances that engineers would somehow solve everything. He had acknowledged the objection and offered a specific answer.

A delay between discharges was a simple proposal, but that was precisely what made it interesting.

"Well," Gussard said at last, folding his arms, "that might actually work."

Around the table, the committee's attention sharpened.

There were still questions to ask, figures to challenge, and practical difficulties to examine. Nobody had yet approved the battleship, and a convincing answer about one aspect of its armament did not settle the others.

But the young man before them had arrived prepared. He understood the objections well enough to anticipate them, and he possessed answers that required consideration rather than indulgence.

Oskar rested his hand beside the notebook and waited for the next question.

The meeting had scarcely begun, and dismissing him was already proving more difficult than they had expected.

More Chapters