Chapter 43 : THE INQUISITOR RETURNS
The portal opened in the Institute's receiving chamber at precisely nine in the morning.
Inquisitor Imogen Herondale stepped through with the particular authority of someone who expected everyone to notice her arrival and feared the consequences if they didn't. Behind her came two Clave functionaries carrying document cases, their faces carefully blank.
I was waiting.
"Inquisitor." I offered the formal bow required by protocol. "Welcome to the New York Institute."
"Mr. Lightwood." Her gaze swept the chamber, cataloguing every detail. "You've redecorated since my last visit."
"We repaired battle damage. The aesthetics were incidental."
"Hmm." She moved past me into the main corridor, not waiting for an escort. "I trust you've prepared the documentation I requested? Monthly reports on rune anomalies, alliance activities, operational decisions?"
"Everything is in order."
"We'll see."
The inspection lasted six hours.
Imogen examined every report, questioned every decision, probed every aspect of how I'd led the Institute since her previous visit. The alliance with Luke's werewolves drew particular scrutiny — pages of questions about authority structures, communication protocols, the "unprecedented" level of coordination between Shadowhunters and Downworlders.
"You've given them access to Institute intelligence," she said, reviewing a patrol coordination document. "Werewolves knowing where our forces deploy, when we're vulnerable."
"I've shared tactical information necessary for joint operations. The same information we'd share with any allied force."
"Werewolves aren't allies. They're Downworlders — creatures we monitor and control, not partners we collaborate with."
"Those 'creatures' helped us defeat Valentine's assault. Without their support—"
"Without their support, you might have been forced to request proper Clave reinforcement instead of building your own private army." Imogen's eyes were cold. "The Accords exist for a reason, Mr. Lightwood. Shadowhunters lead. Downworlders follow. That arrangement has kept peace for centuries."
"And Valentine nearly destroyed it in weeks." I kept my voice level despite the anger coiling in my chest. "The old arrangements weren't working. I adapted."
"You innovated. Dangerously." She set down the documents. "I'm not here to debate policy. I'm here to ensure compliance with Clave oversight requirements. Your paperwork is technically acceptable." The word technically carried enough contempt to fill the chamber. "But I'll be watching, Mr. Lightwood. Very closely."
Sebastian found us during the afternoon session.
He approached with perfect timing — just as Imogen was reviewing training evaluations and growing visibly frustrated with my unconventional methods. His entrance was humble, respectful, exactly calibrated to appeal to traditional Clave sensibilities.
"Inquisitor Herondale." He bowed with fluid grace. "I apologize for the interruption. I was told you might want to observe our training protocols firsthand?"
Imogen's expression shifted. Interest replaced frustration.
"Sebastian Verlac, yes? The transfer from London?"
"That's right, ma'am. I've been here five weeks now — long enough to understand Acting Head Lightwood's approach, if you have questions I might answer."
Smooth. So smooth.
I watched him perform — the perfect traditionalist Shadowhunter, expressing carefully measured concerns about alliance protocols while praising the Institute's overall efficiency. Every word positioned him as a reasonable voice amid my apparent radicalism.
"The Downworld coordination is certainly effective," Sebastian said, "but some of us wonder about the long-term implications. If werewolves become accustomed to equal partnership, will they accept proper Clave authority when this crisis ends?"
"An excellent question." Imogen turned to me with raised eyebrows. "One your reports don't address, Mr. Lightwood."
"Because it's based on a flawed premise." I met Sebastian's eyes. "The werewolves aren't accepting 'equal partnership' as a temporary measure. They're demonstrating what sustainable Downworld relations could look like if we abandon outdated prejudices."
"Prejudices that have kept us alive for millennia," Imogen countered.
"Prejudices that nearly got us killed last month."
The tension stretched between us — Inquisitor, impostor, and heretic, each playing roles in a game whose rules kept shifting.
Sebastian broke it with a self-deprecating smile.
"I'm sure these are matters for leadership to resolve. I just wanted to offer the Inquisitor my perspective as a recently arrived observer." He bowed again. "If there's anything I can do to assist with the inspection, please let me know."
"Thank you, Mr. Verlac." Imogen's voice had warmed considerably. "It's refreshing to meet a young Shadowhunter with proper respect for tradition."
Sebastian left with another bow, and I watched him go with murder barely contained behind my professional mask.
He's building allies. Using the Inquisitor's visit to position himself as the reasonable alternative to my leadership.
The trap was closing, and I still couldn't prove anything.
Jace found me after Imogen retired to her guest quarters.
"She's asking questions about you," he said without preamble. "Personal questions. About your judgment, your loyalties, whether your abilities have... affected your priorities."
Through the parabatai bond, I felt his discomfort — the particular tension of someone caught between competing obligations.
"What did you tell her?"
"The truth. That you're the best commander I've ever served under, that your decisions during the battle saved lives, that the alliance you built is the only reason we're still alive." Jace's jaw tightened. "She wasn't satisfied."
"She wanted you to admit I'm dangerous."
"She wanted me to choose." He met my eyes. "Between my parabatai and my grandmother. Between the bond and the blood."
The weight of that choice settled between us. In the show, Jace had struggled with family loyalty throughout — his connection to Valentine, to the Herondales, to everyone who claimed him. I'd tried to give him stability, but some pressures couldn't be avoided.
"And if she asks you to report me? To document my 'heresies' for Clave prosecution?"
Silence stretched.
"You saved Max." Jace's voice was rough. "You threw away everything the Clave values to save my brother — your brother. My parabatai." He stepped closer, and through the bond I felt his certainty solidify. "That's the only answer she needs to hear, even if she doesn't like it."
Relief flooded through me — more than I'd expected, more than I'd allowed myself to hope for.
"Thank you."
"Don't thank me." Jace's expression was grim. "Just make sure we survive whatever's coming. Because she's not going to stop, Alec. And Sebastian..." He shook his head. "There's something wrong with him. I can't explain it, but every time we train together, something feels off."
Your instincts are better than you know, brother.
"I'm working on it."
"Work faster."
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.