"Wearing imperial robes and accepting an honorific title?"
Zhao Pu caught the astonishment in the emperor's voice and glanced sideways. Unfortunately, all he saw was His Majesty's familiar dark complexion. There was not much to read from that face.
Well, the emperor had always been dark-skinned. It was hardly easy to tell whether his expression had changed.
Still, Zhao Pu understood why His Majesty was so surprised.
Even setting aside the present age, the Tang Dynasty's customs and political atmosphere had changed considerably after the An Lushan Rebellion. By then, they were already quite different from those of the Zhenguan and Kaiyuan eras.
Under such circumstances, a woman ruling from behind the curtain was hardly shocking. But putting on imperial ceremonial robes, accepting an honorific title, and openly appearing before the court dressed like an emperor? That was another matter entirely. It was difficult to imagine such a spectacle.
As for the story of a court official openly submitting a memorial urging Liu E to follow Wu Zetian's example, Zhao Pu simply took note of it and moved on.
How much of that memorial was genuine conviction, and how much was merely an attempt to test the waters? There was plenty of room for debate.
Zhao Guangyi, meanwhile, felt considerably more at ease.
Just look at his elder brother's descendants. Whatever they could be praised for, very little of it had anything to do with the actual duties of an emperor.
What kind of ruler earned praise mainly for things outside his responsibilities as the Son of Heaven? Surely, that was hardly a good sign.
Feeling rather pleased with this thought, Zhao Guangyi casually voiced his agreement with the assessment on the Light Screen.
"I'd say that assessment is much more accurate. Rather than calling Wu Zetian's style of rule flamboyant, I think it resembled the way Emperor Taizong conducted himself back when he was still Prince of Qin."
"She personally led charges against enemy formations and fought at the front. She relied on the authority and prestige earned through those military achievements to intimidate her opponents. And when it came to seizing control of the court and keeping everyone in line, her methods were every bit as ruthless."
Zhao Kuangyin gave his younger brother a sideways glance after hearing that lengthy analysis. Then he turned to Zhao Pu, his tone suddenly becoming much friendlier.
"Zeping, do you understand how this Jiaozi Office operates?"
Zhao Pu lowered his head, pretending to give the question some serious thought while secretly suppressing a chuckle.
The Prince of Jin really did have a knack for saying things that were better left unsaid.
If Wu Zetian was being compared to Li Shimin during his days as Prince of Qin, then who was Liu E supposed to resemble? Later generations had described her as Wu Zetian's complete opposite.
Was she supposed to be compared to Crown Prince Li Jiancheng, the unfortunate soul who had died at Xuanwu Gate?
There was hardly any point in pursuing that comparison.
Still, Zhao Pu could not help recalling what His Majesty had said earlier about Emperor Zhenzong's shameless attempt to perform the Fengshan sacrifice. Then there was the matter of the alliance with the Liao and the annual payments made to them. Whenever those subjects came up, the emperor seemed to swallow half his words before they could leave his mouth.
Thinking about it gave Zhao Pu a familiar sense of helplessness.
Nevertheless, since Zhao Kuangyin had asked him directly, he gathered his thoughts and answered seriously.
"Yizhou has enjoyed a thriving commercial economy since ancient times, but it has always been short of gold and copper. The merchants of Shu know how to make money. Their biggest headaches are poor-quality iron and debased coinage."
"I heard about this even when I was in Heyang. In Shu, buying a single bolt of silk could require a mule to carry a hundred jin of iron coins. It causes considerable inconvenience."
Zhao Kuangyin immediately understood.
A single bolt of silk weighed barely one and a half jin, yet purchasing it required a hundred jin of iron coins?
No wonder merchants preferred to calculate prices in silk rather than deal with such a ridiculous amount of cumbersome currency.
But if a thin sheet of paper called jiaozi could represent the value of that one-and-a-half-jin bolt of silk, effectively replacing a hundred jin of iron coins, what merchant in his right mind would refuse to use it?
The advantages were obvious.
But so were the risks.
"Credit currency? Excessive issuance? Stripping the common people of their wealth?"
Zhao Kuangyin recognized every individual character. The problem was that once those characters were put together, the meaning escaped him completely.
And the Light Screen was not making things any easier. It had practically gone out of its way to point out that ancient officials could not even properly understand a conventional coin-based monetary system, let alone a credit-based one.
Zhao Kuangyin was beginning to feel anxious.
It was like standing right in front of an enormous mountain of gold, only to discover that there was no entrance.
He could see the treasure. He knew it was there. He simply had no idea how to get inside.
Few things were more frustrating.
Beside him, Zhao Guangyi had been left out of the discussion, but he did not seem offended. Instead, he quietly wrote down several unfamiliar terms.
Scratch, scratch....
Annual payments. Heavenly Book. Farce. Fengshan sacrifice.
He planned to study them carefully later and see whether he could piece together the full story.
There was clearly more connecting these events than he currently understood.
But one question still bothered him.
Why had his elder brother never told him about any of this?
***
The moment the jiaozi appeared on the Light Screen, Liu Bei immediately grew tense.
"Kongming, those gold notes being issued in Yizhou…"
"My lord, there is no need to worry. We have already stopped printing new gold notes, and the amount in circulation is strictly controlled."
"From Dujiangyan all the way to the Eastern Sea, merchants everywhere are eager to obtain Yizhou gold notes to facilitate their trade."
Kongming first reassured his lord. Then he subtly nodded toward Lu Su.
Lu Su understood the hint. With a helpless expression, he rose to his feet as well.
"What Kongming says is true. Before leaving Jiangdong, I had already heard about them. During the New Year celebrations, the Gu clan even spent a considerable sum purchasing gold notes to use as auspicious tokens."
In other words, the Gu family considered these pieces of paper valuable enough to serve as New Year charms.
Truthfully, Lu Su was beginning to appreciate what later generations meant by credit currency.
No matter how sophisticated their anti-counterfeiting measures might be, those gold notes were still nothing more than paper. They were neither gold, copper, nor silk.
Yet the wealthy families of Jiangdong were willing to accept them for two very compelling reasons.
First, the Shu brocade and Shu sugar they could purchase with those notes could be resold for several times their original cost. The profit alone made the arrangement worthwhile.
Second, and perhaps more importantly, they had been impressed by Lord Xuande's military achievements. Cao Cao had been defeated in Jingzhou, Yizhou and Hanzhong had fallen into Liu Bei's hands in rapid succession, and now even Guanzhong had been secured.
Lu Su could already imagine what was happening behind closed doors among Jiangdong's great families. Although they were nominally loyal to Marquis Sun, many of them would probably be willing to offer handsome premiums to acquire more of these gold notes.
After all, credit was ultimately a matter of trust. People accepted something as payment because they believed others would accept it in turn.
Viewed from that perspective, the gold notes Kongming had quietly introduced were a remarkable testament to just how many people trusted Lord Xuande.
Zhuge Liang, however, was not entertaining the same complicated thoughts as Lu Su.
He was simply examining the surviving design of the Song Dynasty's jiaozi displayed on the Light Screen, wondering whether it might be worthwhile to issue another batch of gold notes.
Naturally, such a decision could not be made on a whim.
He would first need to gather market data from Jiangling, Chengdu, Hanzhong, and other major cities. Using mathematics, they would calculate the actual shortage of currency. Then they would compare the figures against agricultural output and the production capacity of local workshops before preparing a formal proposal.
In fact, Zhuge Liang had approached this experiment with paper currency very cautiously from the beginning.
The value of their gold notes was anchored by the goods stored in Chengdu's warehouses. Their circulation was supported by the official markets under Lord Xuande's control. On top of that, Liu Bei's military achievements and reputation provided an additional layer of public confidence.
They also needed Liu Ba, a man well versed in finance and commerce, to remain in Chengdu and oversee the entire operation.
Only with all these safeguards in place had Zhuge Liang dared to introduce the system, advancing one careful step at a time.
***
"So this paper currency policy isn't simply another scheme to seize the people's wealth, like the White Deer Skin Currency?"
Li Shimin blinked. His thoughts began to stir, but his instincts quickly suppressed the growing interest.
Later generations had criticized the Song Dynasty on countless fronts, yet they still praised its remarkable commercial prosperity. Even so, despite all that wealth, the Song had been criticized for failing to understand currency.
There was no need to mention his own Tang Dynasty, then.
True, later generations had also mentioned how debased coinage would eventually become a serious problem in the Jianghuai region. But that particular disaster had not happened yet. There was no need to worry about it just now, was there?
As for the difference between jiaozi and the White Deer Skin Currency, the ministers could recognize it at a glance. The Light Screen had also made the cause of jiaozi's eventual decline perfectly clear. The government had issued far too much of it without proper control.
For a while, everyone furrowed their brows and fell into thought.
Before long, however, Zhangsun Wuji let out a sigh. Fang Xuanling and Du Ruhui exchanged glances before shaking their heads together.
"If the government establishes a proper office to regulate its issuance, this could very well become a policy that benefits the people," Du Ruhui said approvingly.
"But the problem of excessive issuance would be extremely difficult to eliminate," Fang Xuanling countered, his tone considerably firmer.
Zhangsun Wuji let out a series of cold laughs.
"To implement such a policy, the emperor must be able to understand the affairs of the state, officials must have no desire to enrich themselves, and government clerks must be capable and diligent."
"Otherwise, the moment a famine or war breaks out, this currency could become even more harmful to the people than debased coinage. It might offer the state one benefit, but it would bring a hundred disasters."
One benefit, a hundred harms.
That was Zhangsun Wuji's verdict on credit currency, and Fang Xuanling agreed with him.
Du Ruhui, however, was unusually unwilling to back down.
"Consider this. If our Tang Dynasty obtains Champa rice, develops maritime trade, and pacifies the surrounding territories, the state's financial needs will grow many times beyond what the Former Han once required."
"The demand for gold and copper currency will also multiply. Yet the supply of good-quality coinage will hardly keep pace. That is precisely how the problem of debased money takes root."
"And look at what the Light Screen has just explained. Currency backed by the reputation of the state itself is a better path forward. Now that we know such a method exists, should we really cast it aside like an old shoe simply because we fear it might be abused? What would that make us? People who refuse to eat ever again just because they once choked on a mouthful?"
Both sides stood their ground, neither willing to yield. In the end, they left the decision entirely to Li Shimin.
It was a rare sight.
Ask the Tang emperor how to charge straight at an enemy commander and break through an opposing formation, and he could talk for ten thousand words without running out of breath. But bring up taxation, state revenue, and monetary policy, and his mind would suddenly go blank.
Tap, tap....
Li Shimin lightly tapped the table as he looked from one minister to the other. Neither side showed any intention of backing down.
He was genuinely at a loss.
Empress Zhangsun noticed her husband's predicament and gently offered a suggestion.
"In my opinion, since the advantages and disadvantages are so difficult to weigh, why doesn't Your Majesty establish markets for trading sheep in Yunnei, Mayi, and other suitable places? We could select just one market for a trial period of one or two years and carefully observe the results. Once we have a clearer picture, Your Majesty can judge the gains and losses before making a final decision."
Li Shimin's eyes immediately lit up.
Whether the experiment succeeded or failed, the Turkic elders could give their verdict first.
What a pity. He had finally obtained a policy from a later age, one that might surpass anything available in his own time. Yet testing it within the Tang Dynasty meant risking his own people's wealth.
There was only one sensible solution.
Let the Turkic brothers experience it first!
The title of Heavenly Qaghan above the Second Son of the Li family's head suddenly seemed to shine a little brighter.
"Very well. We shall follow the Empress's suggestion."
With that matter settled, the Tang emperor turned his attention to the Qing Dynasty. His curiosity had now reached an entirely different level.
"A declaration of war against all the nations? How on earth did the Qing end up in such a peculiar situation?"
Under ordinary circumstances, hearing that a dynasty had declared war on every major power in the world would have left Li Shimin astonished.
But by now, he knew that from the Ming Dynasty onward, China had gradually fallen behind the Western powers in terms of national strength. The Light Screen had also mentioned that the Qing Dynasty was eventually forced to surrender after being defeated by a foreign expeditionary force numbering barely more than ten thousand men.
Later generations had summed up the cause of this humiliation in just a few words: closing the country off from the outside world.
Putting all these pieces together, Li Shimin felt that the Qing Dynasty's grand declaration of war was less an act of courage and more a case of a small-minded regime overestimating its own strength.
But what puzzled him even more was how such a vast empire had ended up in the hands of a woman with so little formal education.
After all, Liu E had been praised for remaining diligent in her studies despite her humble origins. Even after wearing imperial robes and being compared to Wu Zetian, she had still managed to leave behind a favorable reputation.
The young woman of the Wu clan currently serving in his own palace was much the same. She, too, studied with remarkable dedication.
Hmph....How had the Qing Dynasty managed to move backward with every passing century?
