Chapter 430: The Blair House Compact
January 22–23, 1980
Blair House & The White House, Washington, D.C. • The New York Stock Exchange • Seattle • St. Louis • Long Beach • Bethpage
At four-thirty on the afternoon of Tuesday, January 22, 1980, a wet snow mixed with freezing Potomac sleet was ticking against the tall, shuttered eighteenth-century windows of the Lee Dining Room on the first floor of Blair House.
Across the four lanes of Pennsylvania Avenue, behind the black wrought-iron fence and the floodlit portico of the White House, speechwriters were putting the final staples into President Jimmy Carter's fourth State of the Union address, scheduled for delivery before a joint session of Congress the following evening. Inside Blair House, however, the curtains had been drawn since the twenty-seventh of December. Secret Service agents in dark suits stood outside the white-painted double doors; the crystal chandelier overhead burned through a blue haze of cigarette and pipe smoke; and across the twenty-foot length of the Federal-style mahogany dining table lay the dismembered financial and engineering skeletons of three of the most famous names in the history of human flight.
There were no investment bankers from Morgan Stanley or Goldman Sachs in the room. Thornton "T" Wilson had thrown the Wall Street lawyers and the merger-arbitrage accountants out into the second-floor sitting room on the third day of the negotiations, after a thirty-two-year-old Harvard MBA had made the mistake of referring to the Boeing 767 wing-box and the Grumman electron-beam titanium welding chambers as "depreciable non-core balance-sheet capital."
Only eight men remained around the mahogany table:
At the western head sat Thornton Arnold Wilson, fifty-eight years old, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of The Boeing Company, his suit jacket slung over the back of his chair, his white shirtsleeves rolled up over thick forearms, a half-chewed unlit cigar clamped in the corner of his mouth. Beside him sat fifty-eight-year-old Joseph F. Sutter—the Slovenija-descended Seattle aerodynamicist who had led the design of the 747 and now served as Boeing's Executive Vice President of Commercial Engineering and Product Development.
Across the table to the north sat Sanford "Sandy" McDonnell, fifty-seven, Chairman of the McDonnell Douglas Corporation, his patrician St. Louis face drawn and grey after twenty-six days of watching his uncle's company stripped down to its bare rivets. Beside him sat forty-nine-year-old John Capuano, Chief Engineer of McDonnell Aircraft's Tactical Fighter Division in St. Louis—the man whose emergency pulse-Doppler and parallel-array upgrades on the F-15C Eagle had just been baptized in blood forty-eight days ago over the Qezel Ozan gorge in northern Iran.
Across the table to the south sat John C. Bierwirth, fifty-six, Chairman of the Grumman Corporation of Bethpage, Long Island, alongside fifty-eight-year-old George M. Skurla, President of Grumman Aerospace—the hard-nosed aeronautical engineer who had once managed the Apollo Lunar Module at Cape Canaveral and had spent the last five years trying to keep the famous "Grumman Iron Works" alive after the United States Navy truncated the F-14 Tomcat production line following the electronic-warfare disaster off Mauritius in 1975.
And at the eastern end of the table, representing the single customer whose checkbook kept all three companies breathing, sat Secretary of Defense Dr. Harold Brown and his Undersecretary for Research and Engineering, Dr. William J. Perry.
"Look at the red ink on Schedule Four, Sandy, and stop talking to me about the Douglas family crest," T. Wilson said, his gravelly Iowa voice cutting across the table as he tapped a thick, blue-bound Price Waterhouse audit ledger with the blunt end of his cigar.
"I have looked at that ledger every morning for three weeks, T," Sandy McDonnell replied tightly, his knuckles white around his silver mechanical pencil. "Long Beach is an asset worth two point two billion dollars in replacement tooling alone—"
"Long Beach is a hemorrhage that is bleeding forty-six million dollars of cash out of your jugular vein every thirty days!" Wilson barked, not raising his voice for theatrical effect, simply stating a structural load failure the way he had stated wind-tunnel failures in Renton for thirty-five years.
Wilson flipped open the Price Waterhouse ledger to page nineteen and shoved it six inches across the felt pad toward McDonnell.
"Let's read the autopsy out loud so nobody in this room walks across the street to the White House at nine o'clock with fairy tales in his head," Wilson said. "In the twelve months of 1979, how many commercial DC-10 tri-jets did Douglas Aircraft sell outside the United States Government, Sandy?"
Sandy McDonnell's jaw clenched. He did not answer.
"Four," Undersecretary of Defense Bill Perry supplied quietly from the end of the table, reading off the Pentagon's own industrial-base assessment sheet. "Swissair took two. Varig took two. And eleven foreign carriers—led by Singapore, Garuda, Alitalia, and KLM—cancelled twenty-nine existing DC-10 options to sign firm delivery contracts for the twin-engine Samudra and the four-engine Himalaya."
"Four airplanes," T. Wilson repeated flatly. "To break even on the Long Beach overhead and pay the interest on the nine hundred million dollars you borrowed from Chase Manhattan and Citibank totool the DC-9 Super 80, Douglas Aircraft needs to deliver eight commercial wide-bodies and eleven narrow-bodies every single month!
"And why aren't the airlines buying the DC-10 or the Super 80?" Wilson looked down the table at Joe Sutter. "Tell him what our own performance engineers found when British Caledonian let Joe's team inspect the flight logs of their first two Samudras at Gatwick last month."
Joe Sutter took off his horn-rimmed glasses, rubbing the bridge of his nose. Unlike the corporate salesmen who had spent 1977 and 1978 trying to convince Congress that the Indian planes were a mirage, Sutter was an engineer's engineer, and he respected cold physics wherever it came from.
"The Samudra's empty operating weight is fourteen thousand pounds lighter than a DC-10-30 on the same two-hundred-and-sixty-seat cabin footprint," Sutter said quietly, without a trace of rancor. "Part of that is because they eliminated the third tail-mounted engine and the S-duct structural weight in the vertical stabilizer. The rest is because twenty-two percent of their secondary structure—the floor beams, the control surfaces, the engine cowlings, the wing-to-body fairings—is autoclave-cured carbon-epoxy composite, while we and Long Beach are still riveting 2024-T3 aluminum skin panels the way we did on the B-29.
"Add an 8.2-to-1 bypass turbofan that burns eighteen percent less fuel per pound of thrust than the GE CF6-50," Sutter concluded, looking directly at Sandy McDonnell, "and on a transpacific or transatlantic sector, the Samudra saves an airline one point九 million dollars per tail per year in Jet A-1 alone. You can discount the DC-10 to zero profit margin, Sandy, and an airline still loses money flying your plane after thirty-six months. The tri-jet era is dead. It is mathematically dead."
Across the table, John Capuano—who had spent the past five years in St. Louis pouring his life into the F-15 Eagle and the F/A-18 Hornet—leaned forward, his dark eyes flashing with the fierce pride of the McDonnell fighter shop.
"Long Beach isn't the whole company, Joe," Capuano said sharply. "In St. Louis, McDonnell Aircraft turned a net operating profit of three hundred and eighty million dollars last year! Our F-15C assembly line is running three shifts a day supplying Tactical Air Command and the new bases in Mosul and Incirlik. On December 5th over northwestern Iran, Major Dick Bong's F-15C flight went head-to-head with two squadrons of fifth-generation Garudas and Soviet MiG-29s—and our APG-63D parallel-processor radar broke their electronic jamming in twelve milliseconds and brought every single American pilot home alive! St. Louis doesn't need a bailout from Seattle!"
"No, John," Defense Secretary Harold Brown intervened calmly from the head of the table, folding his hands over the red-striped TOP SECRET — PROGRAMME ZERO-SIX dossier in front of him. "St. Louis doesn't need a financial bailout for 1980. What St. Louis needs is two point four billion dollars in clean-sheet R&D capital between 1980 and 1985—and right now, every dollar of profit your F-15 line makes in St. Louis is being sucked down a pipe to California to pay the electric bill on an empty DC-10 hangar in Long Beach!"
Brown opened the Programme Zero-Six intelligence binder—the joint USAF-CIA technical dissection of the December 5th air battle over the Qezel Ozan gorge—and slid two satellite and gun-camera enlargements into the middle of the table.
"Look at the debriefing telemetry from Major Bong's own flight data recorder, John," Brown said, his physicist's voice clinical and unsparing. "Yes, our upgraded APG-63D radar burned through the Indian jammer because they were still running an older 16-bit processor on their Block-I aircraft—a mistake you can bet your life they are already fixing.
"Now look at the aerodynamic and propulsion numbers from that engagement: "Major Bong's F-15Cs had to burn three minutes of full Zone-5 afterburner just to reach Mach 1.65 at forty thousand feet, arriving at the merge with forty percent internal fuel gone. The four Indian S-40 Garudas cruised forty miles uphill from Tabriz to the gorge at Mach 1.42 in dry military power—without lighting their afterburners once! "Their radar cross-section on our AWACS scopes was zero point three square metres—one-fortieth the radar return of your F-15C! "And their twin engines were putting out sixty-one thousand pounds of thrust against forty-seven thousand on the Eagle!
"If McDonnell Aircraft stays a standalone $4-billion company bleeding cash into Long Beach," Secretary Brown said, looking from Sandy McDonnell to John Capuano, "and Grumman stays a $1.8-billion company on Long Island starving for commercial cash flow while trying to build municipal buses in Ohio, and Boeing stays in Seattle trying to fight a Indian industrial monolith all by itself on 757 and 767 commercial margins—by 1986, all three of you will be dead or second-rate regional subcontractors!"
Brown turned to the south side of the table, where John Bierwirth and George Skurla of Grumman sat.
"And the Navy's position is identical, John," Brown said to Bierwirth. "Since July, two eighty-five-thousand-tonne Indian nuclear supercarriers—Viraat and Akashvani(in sea trial)—have been operating or fitting out with seventy-two carrier-borne Starlighters and Makaras apiece, and their third hull is already on the slipway. Our carrier air wings need the upgraded EA-6B Prowler electronic-attack fleet, the E-2C Hawkeye airborne warning upgrades, the navalized F/A-18, and an all-weather, low-observable carrier strike fighter for the late 1980s. Grumman has the finest naval aircraft integration engineers and the largest electron-beam titanium welding bay in the Western Hemisphere sitting in Bethpage—and you are nine weeks away from defaulting on a hundred-and-sixty-million-dollar revolving credit note at Bankers Trust because your commercial bus subsidiary has cracked A-frames!"
George Skurla, a man who had spent forty years on the flight lines of Bethpage and Patuxent River, didn't even try to defend the bus programme. He looked straight across the mahogany table at T. Wilson and Joe Sutter.
"I don't give a damn about the bus company, T—sell it for scrap iron tomorrow morning," Skurla growled. "And I don't give a damn what title you put on my door. I want to know one thing before John Bierwirth and I sign away fifty years of the Grumman Iron Works: who is going to run the combined company—the men who build airplanes, or the bean-counters who wrecked Long Beach?"
Thornton Wilson took the unlit cigar out of his mouth, laid it in the crystal ashtray, and stood up at the head of the table.
He walked over to the large tripod easel that Joe Sutter had set up in front of the marble fireplace, where a four-foot organizational and industrial integration blueprint had been drawn up in Boeing's classic block-diagram style.
"George," T. Wilson said, looking first at Skurla, then at Capuano, and then at Sandy McDonnell, "if any financial controller, cost-accountant, or Wall Street lawyer ever gets his hands on the chief engineer's pencil in this company while I am breathing, Joe Sutter and I have a suicide pact to throw the son of a bitch out the fourteenth-floor window onto East Marginal Way."
A brief, tight ripple of genuine humor broke the suffocating tension among the engineers in the room.
"Let me spell out the exact corporate, financial, and factory-floor architecture on the table right now," Wilson said, tapping the top box of the blueprint with his knuckle, "because at seven o'clock the final typists are coming in, and at nine o'clock we walk across the street to the Oval Office.
"First: The Name and the Equity. "The new corporation is The Boeing McDonnell Corporation—trading on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker BMD—with three principal operating groups: Boeing Commercial Airplanes, McDonnell Tactical & Space Systems, and Grumman Naval & Electronic Warfare Systems. "On the financial ledger: Boeing executes a tax-free stock-and-assumed-debt acquisition valuing McDonnell Douglas at three point four billion dollars ($3.4 billion)—a twenty-eight percent premium over Friday's closing share price—and valuing Grumman Corporation at one point two billion dollars ($1.2 billion), for a total transaction value of four point six billion dollars ($4.6 billion). " Combined backlog on Day One: twenty-four point eight billion dollars. Combined annual revenue: twenty-one point six billion dollars. Combined engineering and manufacturing workforce: two hundred and twelve thousand men and women across Washington, Missouri, California, New York, and Kansas."
Wilson tapped the second box on the chart—the box that solved the bleeding wound in Southern California.
"Second: The Long Beach Surgery. "Effective nine o'clock tomorrow morning, the commercial marketing of the DC-10 and the DC-9 is terminated. We will never again waste a single dollar of engineering blood having Seattle and Long Beach bid against each other to cut each other's throats in front of Delta or United! "What happens to the thirty-eight thousand workers and the ten million square feet of high-bay manufacturing floor at Long Beach? "We don't lay off a single machinist, Sandy!" Wilson looked directly at McDonnell and Secretary Brown. "Under the Defense Production Act package Dr. Brown and President Carter are signing tonight: "One: The last forty-two unfinished DC-10 airframes sitting on the Long Beach line are purchased immediately at cost-plus-five-percent by the United States Air Force Strategic Air Command as KC-10A Extender long-range aerial refuelling tankers! Now that the US Army has eighty thousand men permanently garrisoned in landlocked Mosul and Baghdad and the Navy is operating in the Indian Ocean, SAC needs those tankers yesterday. That wipes out the entire nine-hundred-million-dollar Long Beach commercial write-off at a stroke! "Two: As the last KC-10A rolls out of Bay One in Long Beach, Joe Sutter moves the second final-assembly line for the Boeing 757 and the extended-range Boeing 767 directly into Long Beach—doubling our monthly production capacity from eight twin-aisle jets a month to sixteen! "And Three: Hangars Four and Five at Long Beach become the dedicated prime manufacturing complex for the Air Force's new C-17 Heavy Strategic-Tactical Airlifter—combining Boeing's supercritical blown-flap wing technology from the YC-14 with McDonnell's externally blown flap system from the YC-15 so we stop wasting three years fighting a stupid competition and start cutting metal in April!"
Sandy McDonnell stared at the chart. For eighteen months, the nightmare of shutting down Long Beach—of firing thirty thousand Californians and taking a billion-dollar write-off that would wipe out his family's fifty-year equity—had kept him awake every night at three in the morning. Under Wilson's blueprint, Long Beach kept every single worker, the commercial debt was paid off by the KC-10A tanker buyout, and the factory became the co-producer of the 767 and the C-17!
"And what about the commercial engine gap, T?" Joe Sutter spoke up beside Wilson, pointing to the third box on the easel, labeled PROJECT TITAN-FAN (DPA TITLE VII JOINT PROPULSION CONSORTIUM). "Even with Long Beach helping Renton and Everett build sixteen 767s and 757s a month, if our planes are hanging 5.8-bypass Pratt & Whitney JT9Ds and GE CF6s under the wings while the Indians are flying an 8.2-bypass Sadhak-Max, we are still fighting with one hand tied behind our backs!"
"Tell them what happened in Cincinnati and East Hartford yesterday morning, Bill," Defense Secretary Harold Brown said, nodding to Undersecretary Bill Perry.
Bill Perry opened a second classified folder stamped DEFENSE PRODUCTION ACT — PROPULSION DIRECTIVE 80-04.
"Yesterday morning at ten o'clock," Perry told the room, "Secretary Brown and I met with Harry Gray of United Technologies—Pratt & Whitney's parent—and Jack Welch and Brian Rowe of General Electric Aircraft Engines. "We gave them the exact same ultimatum the White House gave this room: for the past six years, why has Gorakhpur been able to put an 8.2-bypass turbofan on a commercial airliner? Because inside one fence in Uttar Pradesh, the exact same metallurgists who cast single-crystal rhenium turbine blades and powder-metallurgy disks for their military fighter engine walk across the courtyard and put that exact high-pressure core inside their commercial Sadhak-Max!
"Meanwhile, in the United States," Perry said sharply, "Pratt & Whitney has the best single-crystal high-pressure turbine blade technology in America locked inside its military F100 fighter program in Florida, while General Electric has the best high-pressure compressor aerodynamics locked inside its military F101 B-1 bomber core in Ohio—and both companies have spent five years suing each other over patents instead of building an 8.5-bypass commercial engine!
"As of midnight tonight, under Title VII of the Defense Production Act, the Pentagon has pooled the military single-crystal metallurgy patents of Pratt & Whitney and the high-pressure core aerodynamics of General Electric into a mandatory 50-50 joint venture—The American High-Bypass Turbine Alliance (CFM-Ultra / GE-Pratt GP8000)—backed by an eight-hundred-million-dollar DARPA high-temperature materials grant! "By mating GE's nine-stage military compressor and Pratt's single-crystal cooled turbine to an 8.6-to-1 bypass wide-chord hollow-titanium and carbon-composite fan, the prototype engine will run on the test stand at Peebles in fourteen months and certify for the Boeing 767-ER, the 747-300 Ultra, and the C-17 by late 1981—cutting specific fuel consumption by twenty-three percent!"
Joe Sutter's eyes lit up behind his spectacles. "At an 8.6 bypass ratio with thirty percent composite weight reduction from Grumman and St. Louis, a twin-engine 767-ER can fly two hundred and sixty passengers eleven thousand five hundred kilometres at 3.5 cents per seat-kilometre—dead even with the Samudra, with Boeing's global service network behind it! And on the four-engine 747-300 Ultra, we stretch the upper deck, put carbon-composite outer wing-boxes on her, bolt four of those 8.6-bypass engines onto the pylons, and push full-payload range out to fifteen thousand two hundred kilometres—matching the Himalaya city-for-city from New York to Tokyo and London to Singapore!"
"And look at the reverse flow from Seattle back to St. Louis and Bethpage," T. Wilson said, turning to John Capuano and George Skurla and tapping the bottom half of the chart.
"Right now, John," Wilson said to Capuano, "your F-15 team in St. Louis and George's naval strike team in Bethpage are trying to design the Air Force's Advanced Tactical Fighter (ATF) and the Navy's stealth carrier strike aircraft to beat the Garuda—while Boeing's military division in Seattle and Wichita is building the offensive avionics for the B-1B, the E-3 AWACS, and the cruise-missile carriers.
"The minute we sign this paper tonight, the walls between Seattle, St. Louis, and Bethpage come down:
"Grumman's four-hundred-foot Electron-Beam Titanium Welding Chamber in Bethpage—the only facility in America that can weld six-inch-thick titanium wing-carry-through boxes without bolts or rivets—starts fabricating the primary supercritical wing-roots for both the ATF fighter, the 767-ER, and the 747-300 Ultra!"Boeing's continuous-filament Carbon-Boron Automated Tape-Laying Machines in Renton and Wichita are duplicated in St. Louis and Bethpage to lay up the stealth composite skins for the next-generation Air Force and Navy fighters!"And all three companies' avionics divisions—Boeing's AWACS radar integration group, McDonnell's St. Louis digital fly-by-wire and fire-control group, and Grumman's EA-6B Prowler tactical jamming group—merge into a single, twelve-thousand-engineer Boeing-McDonnell Integrated Avionics & Electronic Warfare Directorate, wired directly into Dr. Perry's new sub-micron VHSIC (Very High Speed Integrated Circuit) silicon foundries in Texas and California!"
Around the mahogany table, the three chief engineers—Joe Sutter of Boeing, John Capuano of McDonnell, and George Skurla of Grumman—looked at the diagram on the easel, and then at one another.
For thirty years, they had fought one another like gladiators in a pit for every Pentagon contract and every airline order while their corporate lawyers hoarded patents behind padlocked doors.
Put together under one roof, with every patent, wind tunnel, autoclave, titanium welder, and supercomputer shared across two hundred and twelve thousand workers—they were looking at the largest, most lethal concentration of aeronautical engineering firepower ever assembled in the Western Hemisphere.
"What about the board and the executive committee, T?" Sandy McDonnell asked quietly, the last resistance draining from his voice as he looked at the numbers.
"Fifteen directors on the main board," T. Wilson answered immediately, without looking at a note. "Eight from Boeing, five from McDonnell, two from Grumman. I serve as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer. You, Sandy, serve as Vice Chairman of the Corporation and Chairman of the Defense & Space Executive Committee in St. Louis. John Bierwirth serves as Deputy Chairman for Eastern Operations.
"And on the Operational Engineering Council that actually approves every dollar of R&D and every new airframe design before it ever goes to the finance committee," Wilson pointed his stubby finger around the table, "sit four men: myself, Joe Sutter for Commercial Airplanes, John Capuano for Tactical Fighters & Missiles, and George Skurla for Naval Systems & Advanced Manufacturing. Four engineers. Zero accountants. If three of the four of us say we build an airplane, we build the damn airplane."
George Skurla looked at John Bierwirth, who nodded once, slowly.
John Capuano looked at Sandy McDonnell.
Sandy McDonnell looked down at the gold pen his uncle, Mr. Mac, had given him when the first Phantom II flew in 1958, and then up at Thornton Wilson.
"Call the typists in, T," Sandy McDonnell said. "Let's finish the pages."
2115 Hours EST, Tuesday, January 22, 1980
The Cabinet Room, The West Wing of the White House, Washington, D.C.
At nine-fifteen that night, while the sleet outside turned the North Lawn of the White House into a sheet of glistening white ice, the six aerospace executives and Defense Secretary Harold Brown walked through the subterranean West Wing colonnade and into the warmth of the Cabinet Room.
Sitting at the center of the table beneath the portrait of Abraham Lincoln was President Jimmy Carter.
Three years in the crucible of a tripolar world had burned every trace of the soft-spoken Georgia peanut farmer out of the fifty-five-year-old man sitting in the leather chair. The humiliating winter of November 1977 had taught him never again to let America's energy arteries depend on foreign mercy; the thirty-four-billion-dollar Gulf Coast refinery surge of 1978 and the rapid airborne seizure of Northern Iraq's Kirkuk and Baghdad oilfields in November 1979 had restored his poll numbers to fifty-eight percent as he marched into the 1980 election year to claim a second term; and the classified intelligence briefings from the Qezel Ozan gorge and the Bombay Rupee-clearing summits had convinced him, with the cold certainty of a former nuclear-submarine officer, that the United States was locked in a fifty-year technological struggle for parity with the colossus across the Indian Ocean.
Flanking the President sat Vice President Walter Mondale, Secretary of the Treasury G. William Miller, National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski, Attorney General Benjamin Civiletti, and Michael Pertschuk, Chairman of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
When the four-hundred-page bound execution copy of the Boeing–McDonnell–Grumman Merger and Industrial Consolidation Agreement was laid on the Cabinet table in front of the President, FTC Chairman Michael Pertschuk cleared his throat and opened a thin yellow legal memorandum from the Bureau of Competition.
"Mr. President," Pertschuk began carefully, adjusting his glasses as the corporate titans watched him with stony eyes, "before the White House lends its formal imprimatur to this transaction tomorrow morning, the staff of the Federal Trade Commission and the Antitrust Division of the Justice Department are legally obligated to place a formal warning on the record.
"Under Section 7 of the Clayton Act and the Hart-Scott-Rodino Act of 1976," Pertschuk said, "this merger combines the number-one and number-two commercial jetliner manufacturers in the United States, giving the new Boeing-McDonnell Corporation ninety-one percent of domestic commercial transport capacity—with Lockheed's money-losing L-1011 TriStar scheduled to wind down next year. Simultaneously, it combines the prime contractor for the Air Force's F-15 with the prime contractor for the Navy's carrier fleet and the Strategic Air Command's bombers. Under standard horizontal concentration guidelines, our staff economists note that this would ordinarily trigger an automatic preliminary injunction—"
"Mike," President Jimmy Carter interrupted softly, his pale blue eyes fixing the FTC Chairman with a stare as cold as the ice on the Rose Garden grass outside. "How many commercial airplanes did Gorakhpur and Toulouse sell to international airlines in the last eighteen months while your staff economists were calculating domestic concentration ratios?"
Pertschuk hesitated. "Well, internationally, Mr. President, the market share—"
"Internationally is the only market that exists in aviation, Mike!" Carter snapped, his voice crisp and metallic. "An airplane has wings! It flies across oceans! Measuring 'domestic US market share' between Seattle and Long Beach while a fifty-billion-dollar industrial conglomerate in India is capturing sixty percent of every wide-body order in Asia, Africa, the Middle East, and Europe is like counting how many deck chairs you own on the Titanic!
"Ben," Carter turned to Attorney General Benjamin Civiletti, "read the Justice Department's formal statutory determination into the Cabinet record so Mr. Pertschuk can file it in his drawer tonight and never bring it to my desk again."
Attorney General Civiletti opened a three-page black-bound finding that bore the seals of both the Department of Justice and the Department of Defense.
"Pursuant to Section 7 of the Clayton Act and Title VII, Section 708 of the Defense Production Act of 1950, as amended," Civiletti read in a brisk, final legal cadence, "the Attorney General and the Secretary of Defense hereby certify three binding findings of law and fact: "First: Under the 'Failing Division Doctrine' established by the Supreme Court in International Shoe and General Dynamics, the commercial transport division of McDonnell Douglas at Long Beach lacks the capital and propulsion resources to remain a viable long-term competitor in the commercial wide-body market, as attested by sworn affidavits from the chief executives of United Airlines, American Airlines, Delta Air Lines, and Pan American World Airways. Its absorption by Boeing therefore produces zero lessening of actual future competition. "Second: In the defense procurement market, the product lines of Boeing (strategic bombers, tankers, and airborne radar), McDonnell (land-based tactical fighters and cruise missiles), and Grumman (carrier-borne naval aircraft and tactical electronic warfare) are structurally complementary rather than overlapping. "And Third: By formal Presidential National Security Determination 80-11, signed this evening under Section 708 of the Defense Production Act, the immediate consolidation of The Boeing Company, McDonnell Douglas Corporation, and Grumman Corporation is certified as essential to the national defense and industrial survival of the United States, conferring absolute statutory immunity from all federal and state antitrust proceedings, effective immediately upon signature."
Civiletti closed the folder. The entire domestic antitrust question had been buried under six feet of constitutional concrete in less than three minutes.
"And what about the telex we received from Brussels four hours ago, Bill?" Zbigniew Brzezinski asked, looking across at Treasury Secretary G. William Miller. "European Competition Commissioner Raymond Vouel and the French Transport Ministry are threatening to open an EEC competition investigation in Brussels next week—claiming that a unified Boeing-McDonnell colossus will squeeze Airbus Industrie out of the North American and transatlantic markets."
Treasury Secretary Miller let out a short, dry laugh.
"I spoke to Count Lambsdorff in Bonn and René Monory in Paris on the secure line at seven o'clock tonight," Miller said calmly. "I reminded both of them of two facts: "Fact One: Western Europe is currently suffering thirteen percent stagflation and paying three hundred rupees a barrel in Bombay to keep their lights on, while Eastern Air Lines and TWA are the only two airlines outside Europe considering buying the Airbus A300. "Fact Two: I informed them that if Brussels delays or fines a single Boeing-McDonnell aircraft by so much as one afternoon, the Federal Aviation Administration will immediately suspend the US bilateral landing-slot waivers for Air France, Lufthansa, and British Airways at JFK, Chicago O'Hare, and Los Angeles—and impose a fifty-percent countervailing duty on every European-built Airbus wing-spar entering United States airspace!
"Monory and Lambsdorff called back twenty minutes ago," Miller smiled thinly. "Commissioner Vouel's 'inquiry' in Brussels has been cancelled. The European Community will issue a statement tomorrow afternoon welcoming the American restructuring and asking only that Boeing-McDonnell refrain from signing twenty-year exclusive fleet lock-ins with European carriers."
President Jimmy Carter uncapped his black Parker fountain pen and pulled the Defense Production Act National Security Finding and the KC-10A / C-17 / GP8000 Engine Authorization across the Cabinet table.
He signed both documents in silence, blotted the ink, and looked up at Thornton Wilson, Sandy McDonnell, John Bierwirth, Joe Sutter, John Capuano, and George Skurla.
"Gentlemen," President Carter said quietly, "for thirty years after the Second World War, this country grew lazy because nobody else on earth had factories standing that could touch ours. We let our companies fight each other in courtrooms, we let our engineers get bogged down in ten-year committee reviews, and we looked down our noses at the rest of the world until a country we used to send wheat ships to built a jetliner that out-flew our 747 and a fighter that out-cruised our Eagle.
"Tonight, I have cleared every lawyer, every regulator, and every bank debt out of your path," Carter said, his eyes hard as flint. "You have two hundred and twelve thousand of the finest machinists and engineers on God's earth under one roof. Go build me airplanes that take the sky back."
0830 Hours to 1900 Hours EST, Wednesday, January 23, 1980
The New York Stock Exchange • The National Press Club, Washington • Seattle • St. Louis • Long Beach • Bethpage
At eight-thirty on the morning of Wednesday, January 23, 1980—ninety minutes before the opening bell of the New York Stock Exchange on Wall Street—the Dow Jones broad-tape teleprinters and the Reuters green-screen monitors in every bank, brokerage house, and newsroom across North America and Europe began ringing their mechanical three-bell FLASH alarms in a continuous, frantic staccato:
text
*** BELL FLASH — WASHINGTON / NEW YORK (08:30 EST) *** WHITE HOUSE & PENTAGON INVOKE DEFENSE PRODUCTION ACT TO APPROVE LARGEST INDUSTRIAL MERGER IN AMERICAN HISTORY: BOEING (BA), MCDONNELL DOUGLAS (MD), AND GRUMMAN (GQ) CONSOLIDATE INTO $21.6-BILLION "BOEING MCDONNELL CORPORATION" (NYSE: BMD) IN $4.6-BILLION ALL-STOCK & DEBT ACCORD TO COUNTER FOREIGN AEROSPACE COMPETITION. -- PENTAGON AWARDS IMMEDIATE $4.8B IN KC-10A TANKER & C-17 AIRLIFTER CONTRACTS TO LONG BEACH FACILITY; -- PRATT & WHITNEY AND GENERAL ELECTRIC ORDERED INTO JOINT DPA CONSORTIUM TO BUILD 8.6-BYPASS ULTRA-FAN ENGINE BY 1981; -- NYSE HALTS TRADING IN BA, MD, GQ PENDING 11:00 AM CONSOLIDATED OPENING.
Down on the main trading floor of the New York Stock Exchange at 11 Wall Street, pandemonium erupted twenty minutes before the ten o'clock bell even rang.
Around Post Four—where the specialist books for Boeing, McDonnell Douglas, Grumman, United Technologies, and General Electric were kept—three hundred floor brokers in blue and maroon jackets stood five rows deep, waving pink and white institutional buy tickets from pension funds in New York, Zurich, London, and Tokyo and shouting themselves hoarse before a single trade could be crossed!
For two years, Wall Street had priced American aerospace stocks as a dying rust-belt sector doomed to be slowly cannibalized by the Indian colossus in the East and state-backed Airbus in Europe.
In a single morning bulletin, the financial math had inverted:
The bleeding wound of Douglas's commercial division in Long Beach was gone—instantly converted into a guaranteed, high-margin USAF tanker and military airlifter cash-cow;The fifty-million-dollar-a-year duplicated overhead of three competing corporate bureaucracies and rival commercial sales forces was eliminated overnight;Every Pentagon dollar spent on fifth-generation stealth fighters, titanium electron-beam welding, and military single-crystal engines in St. Louis, Bethpage, and Ohio was now legally wired directly into the commercial wide-body assembly lines of Seattle and Long Beach; andThe United States Government had just placed the full sovereign weight of the Defense Production Act and the Pentagon budget behind a single, twenty-one-billion-dollar national champion!
When the New York Stock Exchange specialist finally opened the consolidated book for BMD at eleven-fifteen that morning on a single block print of 1.4 million shares, the stock leaped $11.75 a share on the first tick—dragging United Technologies, General Electric, Alcoa, and the entire industrial board upward with it in a buying stampede that pushed total NYSE volume past sixty-eight million shares (the second-heaviest trading day in the exchange's history) and drove the Dow Jones Industrial Average up 34.60 points by the four o'clock closing bell!
While Wall Street roared, the human shockwave rolled westward with the sun across four time zones and four legendary factory floors.
At 8:45 AM Pacific Time inside the cavernous, hundred-acre Everett Wide-Body Assembly Plant north of Seattle—the largest building by volume on the face of the earth, where the first green-chromate wing-stubs of the Boeing 767 sat in their steel jigs beside four 747-200 hulls—twenty-eight thousand machinists, riveters, and stress engineers put down their pneumatic rivet-guns and gathered around the overhead PA horns.
Simultaneously, twelve hundred miles south at Long Beach Municipal Airport, twenty-two thousand Douglas workers stood in the sunlit open bay doors of Hangar One; at Lambert Field in St. Louis, thirty-one thousand McDonnell fighter builders stood beside the grey fuselages of the F-15C line; and on Long Island, at Plant 14 in Bethpage, nineteen thousand Grumman "Iron Works" craftsmen gathered beneath the wings of the EA-6B Prowler and E-2C Hawkeye.
Over the four-city closed-circuit audio hookup from the National Press Building in Washington came the unmistakable, gravelly voice of Thornton "T" Wilson, followed by Sandy McDonnell and George Skurla:
"This is T. Wilson speaking to Seattle, Wichita, St. Louis, Long Beach, and Bethpage," Wilson's voice boomed off the steel rafters of the four great hangars.
"First, before the newspapers give you fifty pages of Wall Street talk, let me give every machinist, every tool-and-die maker, and every engineer on our floors the plain truth in thirty seconds:"Not one single factory gate is closing. Not one single machinist or engineer is getting a pink slip."In Long Beach, the Air Force has bought out the remainder of the DC-10 line as KC-10 tankers, and on Monday morning Joe Sutter's tooling teams arrive from Seattle to convert Bays Two and Three into the second assembly line for the Boeing 767 and the new C-17 military transport."In St. Louis and Bethpage, John Capuano and George Skurla now have the full treasury and the composite and avionics laboratories of The Boeing Company standing behind the Eagle, the Hornet, the Prowler, and the next-generation fighters.
"For forty years," Wilson's voice hardened, echoing across the concrete floors where the B-17 Flying Fortress, the F-4 Phantom, the Apollo Lunar Module, and the 747 had been born, "the three groups of people listening to my voice right now fought each other for every contract in the sky. And while we were busy fighting each other, the world outside changed, and somebody across the ocean built an airplane that took our lunch.
"Well, the family fight is over. Starting this morning, we are one company, one engineering team, and one fist. And we are going back to work to build the fastest, toughest, most efficient flying machines this planet has ever seen."
Inside Hangar One at Long Beach—where men with twenty-five years of seniority had come to work that morning expecting to hear that Douglas Aircraft had filed for bankruptcy—a deafening roar went up from twenty-two thousand throats, hard hats sailing into the air under the massive tailfins of the tankers.
And in Seattle, standing on the third-level wooden catwalk overlooking the 767 wing-box jig, Boeing's chief structural weight engineer turned to the newly arrived liaison metallurgist from Grumman's Bethpage titanium plant, who had flown into Boeing Field on the red-eye flight four hours earlier carrying two rolls of electron-beam welding blueprints under his arm.
"How much weight did George Skurla say your Bethpage electron-beam weld can shave off that center wing carry-through box if we drop the bolted steel splice plates?" the Seattle engineer asked over the cheering on the floor below.
"Fourteen hundred and eighty pounds per airplane," the Grumman metallurgist shouted back, unrolling his blue drawing across the catwalk drafting table. "And we can have the first welded titanium center-box on a freight car out of Long Island in six weeks."
"Pull up a stool," the Boeing man grinned, handing him a red grease pencil. "Let's cut fourteen hundred pounds."
At 6:30 PM Eastern Standard Time that evening, in forty-two million American living rooms from Maine to California, the familiar teletype chime of the CBS Evening News faded out, and Walter Cronkite looked squarely into the lens of Camera One in New York.
Behind Cronkite's right shoulder, the CBS graphic screen displayed the three iconic logos—the slanted Boeing script, the globe-and-missiles of McDonnell Douglas, and the blue diamond of Grumman—merging into a single dark-blue emblem.
"Good evening," Walter Cronkite said in the steady, avuncular baritone that had narrated the moon landings and the wars of a generation.
"In Washington today, the federal government and the titans of American industry redrew the map of twentieth-century capitalism. "With the stroke of President Carter's pen under the emergency powers of the Defense Production Act, three of the most storied names in aviation history—Boeing, the builder of the 747; McDonnell Douglas, the maker of the F-15 Eagle and the DC-10; and Grumman, the Long Island craftsmen who built the Lunar Module that landed Neil Armstrong on the moon—ceased to be rivals, uniting into a single, twenty-two-billion-dollar industrial colossus to be known as The Boeing McDonnell Corporation.
"In any previous decade," Cronkite continued, taking off his reading glasses and looking directly at the camera, "a merger that places ninety percent of American commercial airliner production and half of the Pentagon's tactical and strategic air fleet under a single corporate roof would have been struck down within hours by the trust-busters at the Department of Justice, just as the government broke up the great aviation trusts in 1934.
"Today, the Justice Department approved the merger in less than three minutes. "Why? Because in the blunt words of Defense Secretary Harold Brown at the White House this afternoon, the United States is no longer competing with itself. From the semiconductor valleys of northern California to the aircraft hangars of Puget Sound and Long Beach, the rise of India's massive, integrated industrial conglomerates has forced Washington to abandon seventy years of antitrust orthodoxy in a single day.
"Tonight, in his State of the Union address before Congress at nine o'clock, President Carter is expected to call this the dawn of a 'New American Industrial Compact.' Whether one calls it a compact or an industrial mobilization, one fact is clear tonight: the age of small players in the global sky is gone forever.
"And that's the way it is—Wednesday, January twenty-third, nineteen eighty."
End of Chapter 430
