Chapter 19: Hook Man — Brief Case
[Ankeny, Iowa — October 20, 2005, Afternoon]
The college campus looked like every other Midwestern university Ethan had ever seen: brick buildings, manicured lawns, students in hoodies hurrying between classes. Normal. Peaceful. Completely unaware that a vengeful spirit had killed one of their own the night before.
Taylor Coleman, nineteen years old, found in his car with a silver hook through his chest. The local police had no explanation—the wound was too precise, too clean, and the hook itself had vanished from the crime scene before anyone could photograph it.
"Jacob Karns," Sam said, spreading printouts across the hood of the Impala. "Preacher, executed in 1862 for murdering thirteen prostitutes. His weapon of choice? A silver hook replacing the hand he lost in an accident."
"Let me guess," Dean said. "He's buried in the local cemetery."
"Was. His grave was moved when the church burned down in 1900. The remains were supposedly transferred to a new site, but..." Sam flipped through pages. "The hook was never recovered. It was melted down and made into other silver items—church property that's been passed through generations."
Ethan processed this. Standard salt-and-burn wouldn't work if the spirit's anchor was scattered across multiple objects. They'd need to track down every piece of silver made from Karns's hook and destroy all of it.
His phone was heavy in his pocket. Jo's number, unused since the Roadhouse. He'd been thinking about texting her—something casual, professional, a way to maintain contact without crossing lines Ellen had clearly drawn.
This seemed like the right opportunity.
He pulled out the phone and typed: Hook Man case. Iowa. Silver remains scattered across town. Not a standard burn.
The response came thirty seconds later: Silver? Hard to salt-and-burn metal.
Working on it.
Don't die.
Two words. Simple. But they carried weight—concern wrapped in hunter pragmatism, the kind of sentiment someone gave when they expected to hear back and would notice if they didn't.
"You texting someone?" Dean's voice cut through his thoughts. The older Winchester was watching with an expression that suggested he already knew the answer.
"Research contact."
"Uh-huh." Dean's smirk said everything his words didn't. "Research. Sure."
Ethan pocketed the phone and focused on the case.
[Ankeny, Iowa — October 20, 2005, Evening]
Lori Sorenson lived in the victim's shadow.
She'd been dating Taylor Coleman for three months, had been in the car with him when the Hook Man attacked, and now sat in her dorm room with the haunted expression of someone who'd seen impossible things and couldn't unsee them.
"It was there," she whispered. "In the backseat. I didn't see it get in. One moment we were alone, and then..." Her hands trembled around the coffee cup Sam had brought her. "It was like something out of a nightmare. A man with a hook. He just... reached through Taylor like he wasn't even there."
"Did you see where it went afterward?" Sam's voice was gentle, practiced at extracting information from traumatized witnesses.
"It vanished. Just... disappeared. But I heard something. A voice. It said Taylor deserved it. That he'd sinned."
Ethan's Sin Sense had been humming since they arrived on campus. The Hook Man's presence lingered here—not in this room specifically, but nearby. The spirit was anchored to something close, drawn to this place for reasons beyond simple vengeance.
"Your father," Ethan said. "He's the pastor at the local church?"
Lori's expression tightened. "How did you know that?"
"We did research. The Hook Man—Jacob Karns—was a minister before he started killing. He targeted what he considered sinners, people who violated his moral code." Ethan met her eyes. "The original silver hook was melted down after his execution. Some of it was made into church property. Property your father's church might still have."
"You think... the ghost is connected to our church?"
"I think the ghost is connected to the silver that came from his hook. If we can find all of it and destroy it, the killings stop."
Lori was already reaching for her phone. "Dad keeps inventory records. Everything the church owns, going back generations. I can get you access."
"That would help."
They left her with Dean's card and instructions to call if anything strange happened. Outside, the sun was setting, painting the campus in shades of orange and red that would have been beautiful if Ethan wasn't thinking about a murdered preacher's ghost hunting sinners in the Iowa countryside.
His phone buzzed. Jo again: Any progress?
Found the church connection. Tracking the silver now.
Be careful with consecrated objects. Some churches get touchy about hunters breaking their stuff.
I'll try diplomacy first.
Since when do you do diplomacy?
Ethan almost smiled. Since I started working with the Winchesters. They've got experience with touchy churches.
[First Presbyterian Church — October 20, 2005, Night]
Pastor Sorenson was a man who'd spent his life serving God and genuinely believed the universe made sense. The conversation about his church harboring objects connected to a murderous ghost went about as well as Ethan had expected.
"This is insane," the pastor said, pacing his office. "You're telling me that the silver candlesticks my grandfather donated—family heirlooms—are somehow connected to a ghost that killed my daughter's boyfriend?"
"The silver came from Jacob Karns's hook," Sam explained patiently. "When he was executed, the hook was melted down. Some of it went to making church items—items that have been passed down through your congregation for over a century."
"And you want to... what? Melt them?"
"We need to destroy every piece of silver connected to Karns," Dean said. "Candlesticks, necklaces, anything made from that original metal. It's the only way to end the killings."
The pastor's face cycled through disbelief, anger, and finally something that looked like reluctant acceptance. He'd seen his daughter after the attack. He knew something unnatural had happened, even if he couldn't explain it.
"The candlesticks. A cross that belonged to the first pastor's wife. And..." He paused, memory working. "There's a necklace. Silver, very old. It's been in the church vault since before I was ordained."
"We'll need all of it," Ethan said.
"What are you going to do with them?"
"Melt them down. Permanently."
The pastor looked at the items he'd brought out—objects that represented generations of faith and tradition, reduced to evidence in a supernatural investigation. "This feels like sacrilege."
"It's protection," Ethan said. "The spirit attached to these objects has killed thirteen people originally, and now it's starting again. Destroying the anchor is the only way to stop it."
Pastor Sorenson hesitated for a long moment. Then, slowly, he pushed the items across his desk toward them.
"Take them. End this."
They drove to a construction site outside town—abandoned for the night, furnaces still hot from the day's work. Dean carried the silver objects in a canvas bag; Sam kept watch for security guards or curious locals.
Ethan stood by the furnace, feeling the heat wash over him in waves.
"You sure this will work?" Dean asked.
"Hellfire melts everything." Ethan held up his hand, allowing flames to flicker across his fingers—a partial transformation, controlled and deliberate. "Silver's just metal. It'll burn like anything else."
He took the first object—a candlestick, heavy and ornate—and held it over the furnace. His hand transformed fully, fire erupting from flesh and bone, wrapping around the silver until it began to glow, then soften, then drip into the flames below.
The Hook Man materialized behind him.
Ethan didn't turn. He felt the ghost's presence through his Sin Sense—rage and righteousness and centuries of accumulated judgment. Jacob Karns had believed he was doing God's work, purifying the world one sinner at a time. Death hadn't changed that conviction.
"You can't stop me," the ghost's voice echoed through the construction site. "The wicked must be punished. The sinners must burn."
"Funny." Ethan's voice came out layered, the Spirit's resonance underlying his words. "I was thinking the same thing about you."
He dropped the melted candlestick and reached for the next piece—the cross. The Hook Man lunged, silver weapon gleaming in the furnace light, but Dean's shotgun roared and rock salt scattered the ghost into fragments of light and shadow.
"Keep going!" Dean racked another round. "I'll hold it off!"
Ethan melted the cross, then the necklace, then a ring they'd found hidden in the church basement. Each destruction made the Hook Man weaker, its form flickering, its attacks becoming slower and less coordinated.
When the last piece of silver dripped into the furnace, Jacob Karns screamed.
It wasn't the wail of a defeated enemy—it was the sound of a man realizing that everything he'd believed, everything he'd killed for, was ending. The ghost's form stretched, distorted, and then burned away in a flash of supernatural fire that had nothing to do with the furnace and everything to do with judgment finally being served.
Silence filled the construction site.
"That it?" Dean asked, lowering his shotgun.
Ethan let his transformation fade, flesh crawling back over bone. "That's it. The anchor's destroyed. The ghost is gone."
"Felt too easy."
"Some cases are." Ethan flexed his hand, feeling the residual heat dissipate. "Enjoy it while it lasts."
[Highway 80 West — October 21, 2005, Morning]
They left Ankeny before dawn, putting miles between themselves and a town that would spend weeks trying to explain Taylor Coleman's death. The official story would be something mundane—gang violence, random attack, the kind of tragedy that made people lock their doors at night without understanding why.
Ethan sent Jo one final text: Finished. Nobody died except the ghost.
Her response came a few minutes later: Good. Now find something harder.
Dean glanced over from the driver's seat. "You're smiling at your phone."
"I'm not smiling."
"You're definitely smiling. What's she saying?"
"Nothing." Ethan pocketed the phone. "Research contact. Remember?"
"Right. Research." Dean's smirk returned, wider than before. "You know, when I was your age—"
"You're two years younger than me."
"—I used to text girls too. Usually meant something."
"It doesn't mean anything."
"Keep telling yourself that." Dean adjusted the rearview mirror, still smirking. "Sam! Our boy Ethan's got a girlfriend!"
Sam looked up from his laptop in the backseat, expression somewhere between amused and sympathetic. "Dean, leave him alone."
"I'm just saying. He's been texting the Roadhouse girl for three days straight. That's not professional communication. That's flirting."
"Her name's Jo," Ethan said flatly. "And I'm not flirting."
"Uh-huh."
The highway stretched ahead, endless and empty. Ethan watched the corn fields blur past, thinking about Jo Harvelle and the texts that had started feeling like something more than hunter networking.
His phone buzzed again. Jo had sent a file—case information, coordinates, newspaper clippings about mysterious deaths in Nebraska.
Found something near the Roadhouse, her message read. Vengeful spirit, maybe multiple. Thought you might be interested.
When did you start doing case research?
When I decided to stop waiting for permission.
Dean was right. This wasn't professional communication. But Ethan wasn't ready to examine what it actually was.
We'll check it out, he typed back. Tell your mom we're coming.
Already did. She says to bring whiskey.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1