Chapter 56: Digging Graves at Midnight — The Priests Who Came Before Are Dead
Danny stared at the Ashen estate from across the overgrown lot, face unreadable, and made his decision.
Retreat. For now.
He still didn't know whether Ella was Mary Shaw's true form or simply another puppet she was operating remotely. Burning his best cards on a probe target wasn't smart. He needed information first — a real picture of what he was dealing with — before he committed to anything.
He turned and walked back toward town.
Behind him, inside the estate, something was happening in the locked room on the ground floor.
The spider he'd sent in lay on the hardwood, completely hollow. Not crushed, not burned — hollowed. Its exoskeleton intact but emptied, replaced from the inside with a dense network of fine wooden structures — jointed, intricate, moving with the slow precision of clockwork. The structures extended through every limb, every joint, threading themselves into place like a puppeteer learning a new instrument.
After several minutes, it stood up.
Clumsy at first. Legs crossing wrong, weight distributed badly. But it found its rhythm quickly. Within the hour, watching it move, you'd never know it had died at all.
Its eyes held a dull, flat kind of life.
Mary Shaw didn't waste anything.
The town of Raven's Fair had maybe three hundred residents left, most of them elderly, most of them settled into the particular stillness of people who had stopped expecting things to change. They watched Danny walk the streets with something close to warmth — the uncomplicated pleasure of seeing a young face in a place that didn't get many.
As long as he didn't say the name.
Danny watched them carefully. The way they moved through their routines — morning coffee on the porch, slow walks to the corner store, conversation that went nowhere and didn't need to. All of it felt real. All of it felt inhabited. If Mary Shaw had puppeted the entire remaining population, there was no point investigating anything — he'd just have to find a way out. But he didn't think that was the case. The town felt sad in the way that living people made places sad, not hollow in the way that absence did.
He needed to find Henry Tibbs.
Henry was the last of a line — his father had been the undertaker who prepared Mary Shaw's body after she was killed. If anyone in Raven's Fair knew the specifics of what had happened in those early years, it was Henry.
Danny found him at the funeral parlor on Marsh Street, a weathered man of nearly eighty with white hair and the slow, deliberate manner of someone who had been keeping secrets for so long it had become a physical habit.
Danny laid his Church credentials on the counter.
Henry looked at them for a long moment, then looked up at Danny.
"Son," he said quietly, "you need to leave Raven's Fair. Take your friend and go. Don't dig into this."
It wasn't a threat. It was the kind of warning that came from watching people not take warnings seriously and then watching what happened to them afterward.
Danny pocketed the credentials. He had more work to do before he'd get anything useful out of Henry Tibbs.
Three days later, the service for Lisa Ashen was held at the Raven's Fair cemetery.
Danny stood with Jamie at graveside, watching the casket lower, and waited until the formal words were done before speaking quietly.
"When you were growing up here — was there ever a church in town? A priest?"
Jamie kept his eyes on the grave. "My dad mentioned it once. Said there used to be. Ministers, exorcists — people the diocese sent. But he said they all left eventually." He paused. "I always assumed they just gave up on the town."
Danny thought about Henry's face. The way he'd looked at the Church badge.
They didn't leave.
He was fairly certain now. The priests and exorcists the diocese had sent over the decades — whatever official record described them as having "departed" or "relocated" — they'd had their tongues torn out in the dark somewhere in this town, and Mary Shaw had filed their voices away with everything else she collected.
The Church hadn't abandoned Raven's Fair. Raven's Fair had beaten every agent the Church had sent.
That was worth sitting with for a moment.
Midway through the reception, Jamie was pulled aside by an elderly woman Danny didn't recognize. He used the opening to find Henry again, who'd come to pay his respects and was now standing alone near the cemetery wall.
Danny kept his voice low and even.
"The priests the Church sent here — Mary Shaw killed them, didn't she."
Henry said nothing.
"You don't have to say her name. Just don't deny it."
The old man's jaw worked. Finally: "Every last one of them. Tongue ripped out, same as that poor girl in Derry. The diocese stopped sending people after the third one. Declared this whole town off-limits." He looked at Danny with something between pity and anger. "What makes you any different?"
"I can work with the same forces she does," Danny said. "I have contained supernatural objects. I'm not coming at this with holy water and scripture alone."
Henry was quiet for a long time. The wind moved through the cemetery trees.
"You're different, maybe," he finally said. "But Mary Shaw isn't something one person solves. This has been going on since 1941. She's had eighty years to perfect what she does."
"Then someone has to be the first one to try seriously."
Danny had been underestimating the stillness. He understood that now. A curse rhyme that propagated through generations and kept an entire town emptied out — the intelligence behind it wasn't small. Mary Shaw hadn't just died and left a residue. She'd engineered her own afterlife with a level of deliberate craft that most supernatural entities never achieved.
Walking away wasn't really an option anymore, either. He could feel her attention on him like a hand resting on his shoulder. He was already on her list. Running now just meant she'd take him on her own schedule instead of his.
Jamie returned, his expression carrying something new — urgency threaded through the grief.
"We have to bury Billy," he said. "There's a plot for him next to Mary Shaw's grave. An old woman just told me."
"Henry's wife," Danny said.
Jamie blinked. "How'd you know?"
"Her husband and I just had a conversation." Danny picked up his jacket. "I'll come with you."
Jamie's relief was visible and genuine. Whatever complicated feelings he had about this town and everyone in it, he was glad not to be doing this alone.
They waited for full dark.
It was the kind of night that Raven's Fair seemed designed to produce — mist rolling in off the low ground, the cemetery lit by nothing useful, the trees close enough together that they turned the beam of a flashlight into a wall of shadows. Jamie carried Billy in one hand and a shovel in the other. Danny carried a shovel and kept his other hand free.
Jamie found Billy's plot without too much trouble — there was a small marker, old engraved stone. He started digging.
Danny moved to Mary Shaw's grave marker and began digging alongside it, quietly, without explaining why. The original film's mythology established that her body had been buried with all her dolls — every one of them interred with her, the way she'd demanded. If anything about her physical remains could be used as leverage or as a focal point for containment, he needed to see it.
Billy's hole went fast. Jamie lowered the puppet in, paused — convinced for a half-second that he saw the head turn — and filled it in. The dark and the fog were doing things to his eyes. He was sure of it.
He came over to help Danny.
The fog thickened.
Danny stopped digging. He held up a hand.
Jamie whispered, "What is it?"
Danny was listening. Not to anything audible — to Diana, to the low-frequency wrongness that preceded something genuinely dangerous. The feeling that the temperature hadn't dropped but should have.
"Someone's coming."
From somewhere back in the tree line, a sound began. Small and clear and utterly wrong in this context.
A child's nursery rhyme, sung in a voice that had been dead for over fifty years.
Beware the stare of Mary Shaw...
The words were familiar. Every kid who'd grown up within a hundred miles of Raven's Fair knew some version of it. But hearing it here, from inside the fog, at midnight, while standing over an open grave — it stopped being a rhyme. It became something else.
Jamie found the source before Danny did. He turned toward Billy's fresh mound.
The sound was coming from underground.
"That's not possible," Jamie said, and then didn't say anything else because his voice had stopped working.
"Don't make a sound," Danny said, low and firm. "Whatever happens, don't scream."
The mist parted.
She was tall — taller than made sense — dressed in a Victorian burial gown that had aged into something gray and ruined. White hair framing a face that had passed through death and come out the other side as something theater makeup could approximate but never actually capture. Her eyes were wrong. No whites at all, just flat dead irises that reflected no light.
Mary Shaw walked out of the fog like she owned everything the fog touched, which in Raven's Fair, she did.
Jamie stumbled backward and went down hard.
Don't scream, Danny thought at him. Don't you dare.
"The legend is true," Jamie breathed, barely audible.
Danny stood between Jamie and Mary Shaw, shovel in one hand, and ran a rapid internal inventory of everything he had available to him and whether any of it was going to matter in the next thirty seconds.
He had not anticipated being caught digging up her grave.
He was not certain an apology would help at this stage.
He was going to have to try anyway.
[Reader Event Active]
500 Power Stones = +1 Extra Chapter
10 Reviews = +1 Extra Chapter
Thanks for reading!
20+advance chapters on P1treon Soulforger