Chapter 6: The One Where It All Begins
They arrived at 5:03 PM.
Five of them, taking the orange couch and surrounding chairs like they'd done it a thousand times before. Monica sat in the middle, gesturing while she talked. Ross sat on one end looking miserable. Chandler and Joey flanked the other side. Phoebe perched on the arm of the couch, guitar case at her feet.
I knew their coffee orders before they said them. Had known for years.
Monica ordered first—decaf cappuccino. Then Ross—regular coffee, like yesterday. Chandler wanted a latte. Joey asked for the largest size we had. Phoebe requested something "with good energy."
I made them efficiently, no powers, just solid work. Brought the drinks on a tray and distributed them wordlessly.
They didn't look at me. Why would they? I was furniture. Background. The guy who made the coffee.
I went back to the counter and watched.
Ross was explaining his divorce to people who'd clearly heard it before. Monica was trying to be supportive while also looking stressed about something. Chandler made a joke about commitment that got a small laugh. Joey was checking out a woman at the next table. Phoebe strummed her guitar quietly.
This was it. The group before Rachel. The five-sixths that would become six.
I checked the wall clock: 5:47 PM.
Any minute now.
Monica - 5:51 PM
Monica Geller was having a terrible day that was about to get worse.
Her younger brother was spiraling over his divorce. Her job at the restaurant was a nightmare of screaming chefs and impossible orders. And she'd just realized she'd left her favorite spatula at work, which shouldn't matter but somehow did because it was her spatula and she'd had it since culinary school.
She was mid-sentence about the spatula when the door burst open.
Rachel Green stumbled in wearing a soaked wedding dress, mascara running down her face, looking like she'd escaped from a disaster movie.
Monica's brain short-circuited.
"Oh my God," she said, standing up so fast she nearly spilled her coffee.
Rachel spotted her, and relief washed over her tear-stained face. She ran—actually ran—across the coffeehouse and collapsed next to Monica on the couch.
"Monica, thank God you're here!"
"What happened? Why are you—is that a wedding dress?"
"I ran," Rachel gasped. "I left Barry at the altar. I couldn't do it. I couldn't marry him. The minty smell, Monica. He smells like my father and I just—I couldn't—"
The words tumbled out in a panicked rush. Monica tried to process: Rachel Green, high school friend she hadn't seen in months, showing up in a wedding dress, having clearly destroyed her entire life in the last few hours.
"Okay," Monica heard herself say. "Okay, just breathe. You're okay."
Behind the counter, the blonde barista was watching them with an expression Monica couldn't quite read.
I made Rachel's coffee while she told her story.
Yellow light. Hope. She needed it desperately.
The vision came: Rachel at a job interview, nervous but determined. Somewhere corporate. Maybe retail. The image was fuzzy around the edges, like the future wasn't quite set yet.
I brought the cup to their table. The gang had rearranged—Phoebe had given up her seat, Joey and Chandler were watching Rachel like she was a car crash, Ross looked simultaneously concerned and something else I couldn't name.
"Here," I said, setting the coffee in front of Rachel. "On the house."
She looked up at me—really looked—and I saw the fear and excitement and terror all mixed together in her eyes.
"Thank you so much," she said, and her voice cracked on the words.
Two seconds of eye contact. That was all. Then she turned back to Monica and the conversation swallowed her again.
I went back to the counter and watched the pilot episode unfold in real-time.
Rachel cutting up her father's credit cards with scissors Monica provided. The declaration of independence. The offer to stay at Monica's apartment. Ross's face doing complicated things while he watched the woman he'd loved since high school declare herself newly single.
Around 6:30, more customers arrived and I had to actually do my job. But I kept one eye on the orange couch, watching history happen.
Phoebe started teaching Rachel about "cleansing your aura." Chandler made inappropriate jokes that somehow landed. Joey was surprisingly sweet, offering simple encouragement. Monica went into organizer mode, already planning how to fit Rachel into her one-bedroom apartment.
And Ross. Ross just stared at Rachel like she'd fallen from the sky specifically to ruin and remake his life simultaneously.
Rachel - 7:15 PM
Rachel Green drank the coffee the blonde barista had given her and felt something shift in her chest.
She'd just destroyed her life. Left Barry Farber at the altar. Disappointed her parents. Become a complete cliché—the runaway bride.
But sitting here, drinking this perfectly made coffee, surrounded by Monica and her weird friends, Rachel felt something unexpected.
Hope.
Not certainty. Not confidence that everything would be fine. Just the small, fragile hope that maybe she could figure this out. Maybe she could build a life that was actually hers instead of the one her parents had planned.
The coffee was really, really good.
"Monica," she said, interrupting a conversation about someone's cleansing ritual, "are you sure it's okay if I stay with you? I don't want to impose—"
"Yes," Monica said firmly. "You're staying. We'll figure it out."
Rachel looked around the coffeehouse—the brick walls, the mismatched furniture, the stage in the corner, the smell of espresso and possibility.
This is my life now, she thought. New York. Monica. Starting over.
The terror was still there. But under it, something else was building.
She caught the blonde barista watching them and raised her cup in a small gesture of thanks.
He nodded once and went back to making drinks.
The gang stayed until 9 PM.
I watched them bond. Watched the jokes and the support and the way they fit together like puzzle pieces that had been scattered and were just now finding their correct positions.
Around 8:30, Rachel asked Monica about jobs. Phoebe suggested massage therapy. Chandler made a joke about data processing that fell flat. Ross mentioned the museum might need someone in the gift shop.
They were problem-solving. Becoming friends. Becoming family.
And I was watching from behind the counter, exactly where I'd been for ten years of television. Except this time, I'd actually been seen. Rachel had looked at me. Had thanked me.
It was more than canon Gunther got in the entire first season.
They left together, laughing about something Joey had said. Rachel walked out still in her wedding dress, Monica's jacket draped over her shoulders.
The door swung shut behind them and the coffeehouse felt suddenly empty.
I started the closing routine. Wiped down the orange couch. Collected abandoned cups. Swept the floor.
Terry had already left. I was alone with my thoughts and the lingering energy of what had just happened.
The pilot was over. The show had started. Six people who didn't know it yet had just begun a journey that would change television.
And I'd been there. Had helped, in my small way. Rachel's coffee had given her hope. Ross's coffee yesterday had steadied him. Small interventions, but real.
I locked the door at 9:30 and walked home through cooling September air.
My apartment felt different when I entered it. Same size. Same furniture. But the weight had changed. This morning, I'd been preparing. Now, I was living it.
The notebook came out. New entry:
September 22nd - Pilot episode complete Rachel arrived, gave her yellow light coffee Vision: job interview, corporate/retail Direct interaction achieved: eye contact, thanks Status: She knows I exist
I underlined the last line twice.
Tomorrow, they'd be back. The gang always came back. Central Perk would become their home base, their meeting point, the center of their orbit.
And I'd be there. Not invisible. Not anymore.
I'd be the guy who made good coffee. Who remembered orders. Who was there when they needed him.
Eventually, I'd be more than that.
But for tonight, being seen was enough.
I fell asleep with the window open, the sounds of Manhattan drifting up from the street below, and dreamed of orange couches and coffee that glowed with possibility.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0