Cherreads

Chapter 124 - A Café Worth Remembering VIII

Tyler walked to the round swivel chair in the center of the lounge, turned it slightly, and sat down. The guitar settled against his body. He adjusted the strap, rested his left hand against the neck, and looked at the fretboard for a moment before looking up.

Everyone was watching him.

His heart began beating faster the moment he realized everyone was watching.

He had expected to be nervous. He hadn't expected the room to feel so different once he sat down: the warm lights above him, the cups and plates on the tables, and the quiet clatter coming from the other side of the café.

His fingers stayed still against the strings.

And then the memory arrived, the way those kinds of memories always do, without invitation.

Same age. Same kind of room. Same type of farewell. A different version of himself sitting in front of a crowd with no guitar and no plan and nothing prepared except feelings he hadn't known were too large for the container he'd chosen.

He remembered standing up. He remembered the piece of love poetry. He remembered how it had sounded entirely reasonable inside his head and entirely too much once it left his mouth. He remembered the silence that followed, and Clara's face, and the particular quality of being unable to take something back that is already in the air.

Tyler's thumb brushed across one string, almost without meaning to. A single note rang out and faded.

The old feeling sat in his chest like something waiting to be confirmed.

He could put the guitar down. He could say he'd changed his mind. Aaron had only asked if he had something prepared; there was no obligation here, and nobody would think less of him for sitting back down.

His eyes dropped to the instrument.

The guitar had been with him for years. Not this exact guitar, but the practice, the hours, the slow accumulation of something he'd built alone in his room on evenings that didn't have anywhere else to put him. He hadn't picked it up because of a crowd. He'd picked it up because it was his.

Tyler breathed in slowly through his nose.

Then he let it go.

Something in the back of his head went quiet, the same way a room goes quiet when a decision is made and the deliberating is finally over. The old memory didn't disappear. He simply stopped letting it vote.

You're not that Tyler anymore.

He lifted his head.

I can do this.

His fingers found the first position.

"It's a little old song," he said. "Make Me Yours. I hope you guys enjoy this."

He looked down, settled the guitar against his knee, and began.

The first chord was soft. The second followed it naturally, without hurry, and by the third the shape of the melody had already become clear enough that a few students shifted forward without realizing they had.

Noah stopped fidgeting. Chris, who had been leaning with his elbow on the back of his chair, straightened slightly.

Tyler let the introduction breathe for several bars before he sang.

♫♫ You were no one, just a passing face,

Yet somehow you found your way to this place.

I don't know when, I don't know why,

But somehow you stayed behind. ♫♫

His voice was warmer than most of them expected. Not large, not theatrical, just clear and unhurried, the kind of voice that doesn't try to fill a room but ends up filling it anyway because it isn't fighting the silence.

At a table near the edge of the lounge, a customer who had been mid-sentence with her friend stopped talking. She turned toward the sound without quite deciding to.

Tyler's eyes stayed on the guitar.

♫♫ Whatever you did, whatever you said,

Somehow your voice stayed in my head.

I understand, but still I don't know.

How you became the place I want to go. ♫♫

The last note lingered. He moved smoothly into the next progression, and the melody carried the room forward before anyone had to decide whether to follow it.

Behind the counter, an attendant set down the tray she'd been carrying. She didn't pick it up again.

The refrain arrived with a small shift in the guitar's rhythm, something that opened up underneath the melody like a door swinging wider.

♫♫ Make me yours, my love,

Make me yours, my love,

Make a place for me.

Make me yours, my love,

Make me yours, my love,

Let me be where you are. ♫♫

Clara's hands, which had been loosely folded on the table, had gone still. She was watching him with the particular attention of someone who has stopped thinking about what to think and is simply listening.

Beside her, Eris had gone very quiet.

She had noticed the hesitation before he started. She'd seen the way his shoulders had stiffened, the way his fingers stayed motionless too long, and she had understood without needing it explained that something was holding him in place before he chose to move past it. She didn't know what that something was. But she was paying attention to it now in the same way you pay attention to a door that was briefly closed and then wasn't.

♫♫ Make me yours, my love,

Make me yours, my love,

Build your home inside my heart.

Make me yours, my love...

Just make me yours. ♫♫

The guitar carried the rest of the refrain into an instrumental stretch, and Tyler's right hand moved easily over the strings, his left finding the positions on the fretboard without having to search. The nervousness that had been sitting in his chest had not disappeared, but it had changed into something less like dread and more like the particular alertness of doing something that matters.

He looked toward the window.

The dark glass reflected the lounge back at him: the warm light, the tables, the watching faces. His own face in the middle of it, calm in a way he didn't expect.

♫♫When morning comes and the sunlight grows, 

You're somehow the first thing my heart knows.

I can't explain what you became,

But every sunrise whispers your name. ♫♫

In the kitchen, the chef heard the voice through the open service area and stopped mid-motion. He stood still for a moment, listening, before quietly setting down what he was holding and stepping toward the door.

Tyler felt it without looking up. He could sense the quality of the quiet changing in the café beyond the lounge, the way listening sounds different from simply not talking.

He did not change anything about how he was playing.

♫♫ When you are near, the grey turns gold,

Even the cold feels less cold.

Why does every road you take.

Feel like the one I want to make? ♫♫

His voice had settled fully into the song now. There was no more edge of self-consciousness in it, no calculation about whether the note was right or whether the room was receiving it the way he'd intended. He was simply inside it.

His eyes moved to Chris.

Chris was watching him with a small, genuine smile, the kind that appears when something exceeds what you were prepared for. Noah beside him had gone entirely still, which for Noah was the loudest possible form of paying attention.

Tyler's gaze moved to Clara.

Clara's face brought the old memory back, but Tyler kept playing. He remembered the embarrassment, the helplessness, and how badly he'd wished he could take those words back. This time, he had something more than words to offer.

His fingers moved into the next chord and the memory moved with it, not gone but transformed, pulled into the music and made into something that didn't require anything from Clara anymore. He wasn't singing at her nor he was singing for her. He was singing the way you sometimes revisit a place you once left badly, not to reclaim it but simply to see what it looks like now that you've changed.

♫♫ The roads I knew don't feel the same,

Somehow they all lead back your way.

And even words you shouldn't say.

Sound almost true when you say my name. ♫♫

Clara's expression softened, just slightly. She didn't know what was moving through his head. To her he was her classmate, her friend, a boy who had arrived from Gulmerg with a wrinkled coat and more than they'd expected. She was simply listening to the song.

The guitar moved into a longer instrumental passage, and Tyler let the melody breathe fully through it. He looked toward the window again. The chef had come to stand near the edge of the dining area, apron still on, watching without embarrassment. A customer who had been preparing to leave was still standing near the entrance with his coat in his hands.

Miss Tamiko was at the edge of her office doorway. She had appeared there so quietly that Tyler didn't notice her, though he noticed that the café had gone considerably quieter than a room with thirty-something students in it had any business being.

He looked at his fingers on the fretboard.

♫♫ I don't need forever,I don't need to know why.

Just leave a little room for meSomewhere in your life. ♫♫

The words landed differently now than they had when he'd first learned the song. He'd chosen it because it suited the guitar, because it sat in a register his voice could handle, because it was old enough to have the particular worn quality of something that has already been through whatever it was trying to describe. But singing it here, in this room, with these people, it had acquired a secondary meaning he hadn't quite planned for.

He had once stood in front of people because he desperately needed them to hear something. He had needed the response. He had needed the acknowledgment.

This was not that.

He wasn't playing to be understood. He was playing because the music was good and the people he was playing it for deserved something real.

That was the entire difference.

The final refrain approached and Tyler's right hand shifted rhythm, opening the sound outward.

♫♫ Make me yours, my love,

Make me yours, my love,

Make a place for me.

Make me yours, my love,

Make me yours... ♫♫

He let his voice drop.

♫♫ Just make me yours. ♫♫

The guitar slowed beneath him, the melody releasing its hold on the tempo and letting the sound thin down to almost nothing before he moved into the final passage.

The lounge was completely silent now. Even the soft background noise of the café had seemed to pause, as though the building itself had decided to listen.

Tyler lowered his head over the guitar.

His voice, when it came again, was barely above speaking.

♫♫ You were no one... ♫♫

He paused. His fingers kept the melody moving, soft and slow, while he let the space sit.

♫♫ And somehow... ♫♫

The words almost dissolved into the music before they arrived.

♫♫ ...you became home. ♫♫

He played the final chord.

It rang through the room and hung there, full and unhurried, while everyone waited for it to fade on its own terms.

Then it was gone.

Tyler didn't move immediately. His fingers stayed resting against the strings. He looked at the fretboard for a long moment, the way you look at something after it's finished, checking that you left it the way you meant to.

Then he lifted his head.

The café was quiet in a way it hadn't been all evening.

The chef was still standing at the edge of the dining area, one hand resting on the wall. The customer near the entrance had given up pretending to leave. Miss Tamiko stood in her doorway with one hand against the frame, eyebrows slightly raised, re-evaluating something she thought she'd already understood.

His classmates hadn't moved.

Clara's eyes were bright.

Eris was looking at him with an expression he couldn't quite place. That was unusual. He could normally tell what she was thinking from the smallest change in her expression.

Noah had both arms resting on his knees and was staring at Tyler with the particular look of someone who has been shown something they didn't know existed and is still processing whether it was real.

"So." His voice had come back to its ordinary register, unhurried, as though he had simply been in the middle of a conversation. "How's that?"

He could feel the thoughts drifting through the café, overlapping in a jumble of surprise, admiration, and questions. Even beyond the lounge, people were still thinking about the performance.

Tyler lowered his head and chuckled softly.

Chris was the first to recover. "What was that?"

Tyler turned toward him.

Chris leaned forward, realizing how that sounded. "I mean, how? When did you become a singer?"

"I'm not a singer," Tyler replied with a smile.

"You definitely were just now," Kai pointed out.

Luna nodded enthusiastically. "It was amazing, Tyler! You've never sung in front of us before."

"Never really had a particular occasion to perform," Tyler said.

"Right, but I didn't know you could sing like that." Luna grinned. "You've definitely gained a new fan."

"True," Aria added. "Your voice is incredibly smooth."

"I'm not even kidding," Aaron said, rubbing a hand over his arm. "That gave me actual goosebumps."

More compliments followed from around the lounge. Someone praised his guitar playing, another wanted to know how long he'd been practicing, and a few others admitted they had never imagined Tyler singing at all.

Tyler thanked them one by one, unsure what to do with so much attention beyond accepting it.

His gaze eventually settled on Clara. She was smiling at him, and when their eyes met, she raised both hands and gave him two enthusiastic thumbs-up.

Well, that was worth it.

He returned her smile.

"I had no idea you were that talented!" Noah exclaimed, pulling Tyler's attention back. "That was seriously so cool to listen to!"

"Thanks, Noah."

The compliments continued, but Tyler's attention wandered toward Eris.

She was sitting quietly beside Clara, her expression giving almost nothing away.

His smile faded a little. He furrowed his brows, trying to figure out what was going on with her. Their eyes met. Tyler raised one eyebrow in a silent question.

Eris blinked, then gave him a small smile.

It looked perfectly normal. Almost too normal.

Tyler knew her well enough to recognize when she was brushing something aside. Whatever was bothering her, she wasn't going to tell him just because he asked with his eyebrows.

The silver spark flickered in his eyes as he began to reach for her thoughts. Before he could, a hand landed on his shoulder.

"So, you've been hiding this talent from all of us?" Chris asked, leaning over him with a grin.

Tyler closed his eyes.

Of course. Just when I was about to find out what was wrong, someone interrupted.

"I'm not hiding anything," he said.

"Yeah, yeah. Like we're going to believe you now."

Before Tyler could reply, Chris caught his shoulder and pulled him toward their seats. Noah immediately joined in, already talking about the song, while Kai followed at a more reasonable pace.

The lounge came alive again. Questions and jokes flew across the table, students talked over one another, and someone began arguing that Tyler should perform at the next class gathering too. The excitement spread beyond their group, with a few students still glancing toward him as the party picked up where it had left off.

Tyler settled back into his seat, answering questions while Chris began inventing a history of secret musical training for him.

For everyone else, it was a wonderful surprise. The Tyler they knew was composed, clever, and difficult to read. The boy who had just sung to them seemed different, though no less familiar.

For Eris, it wasn't quite so simple.

She watched him laughing quietly at something Noah said, the guitar now set aside, as though he hadn't just stood in front of the entire café and revealed a talent nobody knew he possessed.

Since when could he do that?

The question came before she could stop it.

She'd known Tyler for years. She could usually tell when he was irritated, when he was amused, and when he was pretending not to care. Everyone said she knew him better than anyone else.

She had always believed that, too.

But she hadn't known he could play guitar. She hadn't known he could sing, let alone sound like that. He had sat down, played an entire song, and revealed a side of himself she had never seen. Then he'd acted as though it were nothing.

How long has he been able to do this?

She couldn't remember him ever mentioning it. Not once.

Maybe there were perfectly ordinary explanations. Maybe he'd learned in his spare time. Maybe he had never found a reason to perform in front of anyone. There was nothing strange about that.

But the explanations didn't settle the feeling in her chest.

It wasn't just the guitar. It wasn't even the singing.

It was that familiar feeling from the past few days, growing harder to dismiss with every new discovery. She kept reaching for the Tyler she thought she understood, only to find that her understanding no longer seemed complete.

Everyone else had discovered something new about Tyler. Eris could only wonder how many other things she had missed.

Everyone says I know him best.

Her fingers curled loosely around the edge of her chair.

Then why does it feel like I don't know him at all?

More Chapters