Cherreads

Chapter 18 - First Impressions Are Polite Lies

The first name was one he remembered well.

Vanessa Bennett.

Next to it, Viola had written: "Elegant, polite, well-spoken. Good manners. Family respectable."

Tyler's heartbeat stilled for a moment.

Vanessa.

The smile that looked like honey and tasted like vinegar. The he soft voice that could mould itself into anyone's expectations. The woman who, in the past life, had entered their home like a blessing and slowly reshaped it into a battlefield without ever lifting her voice.

He kept his face smooth.

A child's face.

But his mind tightened like a fist.

He forced himself to let the air in.

This was the path.

The path that would teach the family lessons they never forgot. The path that would reveal every weakness, every crack, every hidden truth.

The path he would guide them through not erase.

Viola tapped the paper proudly. "She is a lovely girl. Very respectful. Always greets elders properly."

Steven swallowed. "Um… maybe we should… meet her later? Someday?"

"No," Viola said firmly. "This week."

Steven's soul visibly left his body.

Silas stepped in, voice gentle. "Mother, at least let them prepare. Meeting someone's family is not simple."

"It is simple," Viola said. "You go, you talk, you smile. Then we judge if their soup is edible."

Richard's eyebrows rose. "Why is soup involved?"

Melissa giggled. "Mother uses soup to judge character."

"Soup," Viola declared solemnly, "reveals soul."

Steven whispered to Tyler, "Tyler, do YOU understand any of this?"

Tyler blinked. "No."

But internally, he understood everything.

Vanessa's soup had been flawless.

Her smile even more so.

Next to Vanessa's name was another:

Pamela Reid.

Notes: "Quiet girl. Good family. Emotional, shy. Serious nature."

 Pamela. A woman with a rigid spine and a heart soft enough to bruise at the slightest pressure. Her flaws weren't malicious like Vanessa's they were born of insecurity and influence. She didn't want to hurt anyone. But hurt she did, eventually. And herself most of all.

Tyler swallowed a breath and let it sit in his chest.

This was fate knocking quietly, the first footstep of a future he already knew intimately.

He knew the order: Vanessa first, Pamela second. First the sweetness, then the tension.

He remembered the timeline so vividly that sometimes it felt like reliving an echo.

Silas cleared his throat. "Mother, maybe… let's talk calmly about this."

Viola turned to him with the righteous authority of a judge who carried both wisdom and wooden spoons. "Calm talk is for people who have time. Your brothers do not."

"Mother, I" Steven started.

"No." Viola's finger pointed at him like divine judgement. "You will meet the Bennetts. You will go with me. You will speak politely."

Richard tried his luck. "Can I opt out?"

"No. You must also come. They have a younger daughter beautiful, polite, quiet. She smiles gently. She would suit you."

Richard's entire posture collapsed.

Tyler watched as the family began spiraling into animated negotiation.

Steven: "I'm not ready!"

Viola: "You have been ready since birth."

Richard: "What if the girl doesn't like me?"

Viola: "Impossible. Everyone likes you except yourself."

Melissa: "Maybe we should let them breathe…"

Silas: "Everyone, calm down. It's just meeting. Not a wedding."

Viola: "It could become one! "

Steven: "NO!"

Richard: "NO!"

Tyler sat quietly, hugging his knees.

The play was unfolding exactly as he remembered. The lines, the arguments, even the tone everything felt like déjà vu written into the bones of the world.

He could almost hear his past self, older, tired, and watching the family fracturing slowly after these marriages began.

The laughter that turned into whispers.

The whispers that turned into sharpness.

The sharpness that turned into distance.

He knew every turning point.

"I have seen this ending before.Some things do not deserve salvation.They exist only to collapse,so the road ahead may be walked without illusion."

Tyler said nothing. He would not remove Vanessa from their path. He would not stop Pamela from entering their lives. He would not rewrite this chapter of fate not yet.

But he would be ready.

Melissa sat beside him and stroked his hair gently. "Tyler? What do you think about all this?"

He looked up at her warm, familiar face.

"It's… noisy," he said simply.

Melissa laughed softly. "It always is, sweetheart."

Silas smiled at him, tired but warm. "Don't worry. It's just… family stuff. Nothing scary."

Tyler nodded, even though he knew that some parts would be scary ugly, even but also meaningful.

In the corner, Viola slapped the notebook shut decisively.

"It is settled! Tomorrow we visit the Bennetts!"

Steven choked.

Richard prayed silently.

Melissa smiled nervously.

Silas exhaled.

Tyler closed his eyes.

And so it begins again.

The winds had indeed begun to shift quietly, invisibly, but with purpose.

And Tyler, sitting small among the laughter and groans of his family, felt the full weight of tomorrow.

The house woke earlier than usual, the kind of early that felt deliberate.

Tyler noticed it the moment he opened his eyes. Doors closed more carefully. Footsteps were quieter but faster. The kitchen smelled not just of tea, but of effort of things being made right. mornings were usually loose and forgiving; today they were pressed flat, ironed into shape.

He slid out of bed and padded down the hall.

Steven was already up, standing in front of the mirror with his shirt half-buttoned, frowning at his own reflection as if it had personally offended him.

"Does this make me look serious," Steven asked the air, tugging at the collar, "or like I'm pretending to be serious?"

Viola appeared instantly at his elbow. "You are pretending," she said. "Button it properly."

"I did button it."

"You buttoned it wrong."

"There is no wrong way to button"

"There is," Viola snapped, reaching out and redoing the top two buttons herself. "And this is it."

Richard stepped out of his room next, already dressed but plainly. Clean shirt. Clean trousers. 

Viola turned on him like a hawk.

"That's it?" she demanded.

Richard blinked. "It's… clean?"

"You look like you're going to buy groceries"

"I do buy groceries."

"Today you are meeting people," Viola said. "Important people. You must look like you respect them."

Silas emerged from the bedroom adjusting his watch, calm as ever. "He looks fine, Mother."

Viola sniffed. "You always say that. And then people think... never mind"

Melissa followed behind Silas, smoothing her hair with both hands. She smiled when she saw Tyler hovering near the hallway, already dressed and quiet.

"Good morning, Ty," she said, kneeling to straighten his collar. "Did you sleep well?"

"Yes," Tyler answered.

He watched the scene like a familiar ritual. He had seen this exact choreography before Viola pacing, Steven posturing, Richard enduring, Silas mediating, Melissa softening the edges. Different morning, same structure.

This is the first mask, Tyler thought. How we want to be seen.

Breakfast was brief and functional. No one lingered. Steven barely touched his food. Richard drank his tea too fast. Viola reviewed her notebook between bites, lips moving silently. Silas ate normally, eyes moving between faces, grounding the room without saying much. Melissa kept glancing at the clock.

They left together.

The walk then short ride was quiet in the way of people conserving energy. Steven tapped his fingers against his knee. Richard stared out the window. Viola rehearsed names under her breath. Silas looked ahead. Melissa folded her hands in her lap. Tyler watched reflections slide across the glass.

He remembered this ride.

Not every detail, but the feeling that moment before a door opens and life tips slightly to one side.

The Bennett house stood on a clean street with trimmed hedges and a gate that didn't squeak. The paint was fresh. The windows shone. Nothing was out of place.

Tyler felt it immediately.

Too neat.

Mrs. Bennett greeted them with a smile that had clearly been practiced but not resented. She was warm, welcoming, her voice soft and pleasant. Mr. Bennett followed, polite and reserved, his handshake firm, his words measured.

Steven straightened. Richard nodded. Viola beamed.

"Come in, come in," Mrs. Bennett said. "You must be the Browns. We've heard such lovely things."

Silas returned the greeting easily. Melissa smiled. Viola stepped in like a queen entering a court she already approved of.

Tyler slipped inside last.

The living room was immaculate. Cushions aligned. Tea already prepared. Everything where it should be. It felt less like a home and more like a demonstration of one.

They sat.

Conversation began with all the right topics. Weather. Work. Community. Religion. Mrs. Bennett spoke warmly of family values. Mr. Bennett nodded at the right moments. Viola relaxed visibly, her posture loosening as approval took root.

Steven began to breathe again.

Then footsteps came from the hall.

"Sorry," a gentle voice said, light and apologetic. "I didn't mean to be late."

Vanessa Bennett stepped into the room.

She was dressed simply but elegantly, hair neat, posture perfect. Her smile was soft, her eyes warm, her presence calibrated to the space like she'd measured it beforehand.

Everyone noticed.

Steven froze for half a second just long enough to be human.

Viola's eyes lit up.

Melissa smiled. Silas inclined his head. Richard straightened unconsciously.

Vanessa greeted them one by one, respectful, polite, voice carrying just enough warmth without spilling. When she reached Tyler, she bent slightly to his level.

"And you must be Tyler," she said kindly. "It's nice to finally meet you."

Her smile never faltered.

Her thoughts brushed Tyler's mind.

oh so he is that brat with weird eyes.

Tyler met her gaze and nodded like any six-year-old would. "Hello."

She smiled a little wider, satisfied.

Tea was served. Conversation resumed, smoother now. Vanessa spoke when invited, listened more than she spoke, laughed softly at the right times. Steven relaxed further with each minute. Viola watched her like a gardener inspecting a promising plant.

Tyler listened.

He listened to the words, the pauses, the careful shaping of sentences. He listened to the thoughts beneath measured, alert, quietly assessing.

So this is the beginning, he thought.

No one raised their voice. No one crossed a line. Nothing was wrong.

And yet, something had shifted.

The door had opened.

The tea cooled at a respectable pace.

Cups were lifted, set down, lifted again. Sugar was offered, declined, then accepted with a polite laugh. Mrs. Bennett apologized for the pastries not being homemade; Viola insisted they were perfectly fine; Melissa thanked her twice anyway. The room settled into that particular rhythm of courtesy where everyone waited half a second longer than necessary before speaking.

Vanessa sat with her hands folded neatly in her lap, posture straight without being stiff. She listened more than she spoke, nodding at Steven's comments about work, praising Silas's patience when he described his job. Each response was measured never too eager, never absent.

Steven found himself talking more than he intended to.

"It's busy," he said, gesturing vaguely. "The job, I mean. But good. Keeps me on my feet."

Vanessa smiled. "Busy is good. It means people rely on you."

Steven flushed, pleased in a way he didn't quite notice.

Viola watched closely, eyes sharp and approving. She liked girls who knew when to speak and when to listen. She liked posture. She liked composure. Vanessa fit every quiet requirement Viola had ever written in the margins of her mind.

Melissa sipped her tea and smiled, the way she always did when a room felt safe. She leaned slightly toward Vanessa when she spoke, a gesture of openness that came naturally to her. Silas stayed relaxed, attentive but neutral, eyes moving between faces like a quiet anchor.

Tyler sat on the edge of the sofa, feet not quite touching the floor, his hands resting on his knees. He watched Vanessa's eyes how they tracked reactions, how they softened or sharpened by degrees. He listened to the space between her thoughts.

They like me. Good.

The older woman matters most.

The quieter man is intersting.

The child….

Vanessa turned to him again. "And how do you like school, Tyler?"

He looked up at her. "It's loud."

She laughed softly. "Schools usually are."

Her thoughts flickered. Honest. Calm. Remember that.

Tyler nodded and said nothing more. A child's answer, perfectly acceptable.

Mrs. Bennett leaned forward, clearly pleased with how smoothly things were going. "We believe family is very important," she said warmly. "Stability, respect… those are things we raised Vanessa with."

Viola's approval deepened. "That is good. Very good."

Steven relaxed back into his seat, shoulders finally dropping. This wasn't so bad. No interrogation. No awkward silences. Vanessa was… easy. Pleasant. Safe.

Too safe.

There was a moment a small one, barely noticeable when Vanessa spoke again.

"I think a home works best," she said lightly, "when everyone understands their place and supports one another."

She smiled as she said it, voice gentle.

Viola nodded. Melissa didn't notice. Steven didn't notice.

Silas did.

So did Tyler.

The thought beneath the words was quick and clean: Order prevents chaos.

Tyler didn't react. He filed it away, another familiar shape in a pattern he knew too well.

Conversation drifted on. Time passed without friction. When Mrs. Bennett suggested another visit, Viola accepted without hesitation.

"Of course," Viola said. "We would be happy to come again."

Steven swallowed but smiled. Richard inclined his head politely.

As they stood to leave, Vanessa walked them to the door. She thanked them for coming, her smile unchanged, her manners impeccable. When she bent toward Tyler once more, her voice softened just a fraction.

"I hope we'll see you again soon."

Tyler nodded. "Okay."

Her thoughts brushed him once more light, curious, already cataloging.

The walk back felt different.

Steven exhaled loudly the moment they were out of earshot. "That… wasn't bad."

Viola hummed in agreement. "She is a good girl."

Melissa smiled, hopeful. Silas said nothing.

Tyler looked back once at the Bennett house. The windows reflected the afternoon light, pristine and distant.

The door is open now, he thought. And everyone thinks that's a good thing.

They walked on, the street quiet beneath their steps, the future shifting just enough to be felt but not yet seen.

The first threshold had been crossed.

More Chapters