Chapter 12: The Sister's Story
October 13, 2008 - Evening - Tedd's Apartment
She took a breath and began.
"Miranda was twenty-eight when she died. Five years older than me, but we'd always been close. She moved to Citrus Heights for work—marketing job at some startup that doesn't exist anymore. I was still in our hometown, working retail, trying to figure out my life."
Lorelei's hands wrapped around her wine glass, knuckles white. The System tracked every micro-expression.
[ **ANALYZING: EMOTIONAL STATE** ]
[ **GRIEF MARKERS: ACTIVE** ]
[ **ANGER UNDERLYING: PRESENT** ]
[ **GUILT COMPLEX: SUBJECT FEELS RESPONSIBLE** ]
[ **ENERGY: 60/100** ]
"She called me the night before. March thirteenth, 2003. Said she had a weird feeling, like someone had been watching her apartment. I told her she was being paranoid. Told her to get better locks and call if anything else happened."
Her voice cracked slightly. I stayed silent, letting her process.
"Next day, her coworker found her. Door was unlocked, like she'd let someone in. She was... they said she'd been positioned. Arranged. Like whoever did it wanted her found a specific way."
The crime scene photos flashed through my memory. Miranda Martins, staged like a doll, brutalized and displayed. Red John's signature, though nobody had recognized it yet.
"The police tried. I don't blame them for failing. They interviewed everyone, checked security footage, ran forensics. Nothing. Six months later, they closed the case. Said they'd exhausted all leads." Lorelei finished her wine in one swallow. "Five years, and I still don't know why she died. Who killed her. If they're out there doing it to someone else."
[ **LIE PROBABILITY: 2% - COMPLETE HONESTY** ]
[ **EMOTIONAL AUTHENTICITY: 98%** ]
[ **SEEKING VALIDATION AND SUPPORT** ]
The room felt smaller now, heavier with her grief. I set my own glass down and chose my next words carefully.
"I looked at the case file," I said.
She blinked. "You what?"
"After you mentioned Miranda's murder, I accessed the cold case database. Not officially—just personal research. I wanted to understand what happened."
Lorelei's expression shifted—surprise, confusion, something that might have been hope.
"Why would you do that?"
"Because you deserved to know I took it seriously. And because..." I paused, considering how much to reveal. "The way she was found. Certain details. They match patterns I've seen in other unsolved cases."
Her attention sharpened like a blade. "What patterns?"
[ **CRITICAL MOMENT: INFORMATION DISCLOSURE** ]
[ **CHOOSE WORDS CAREFULLY** ]
[ **ENERGY: 58/100** ]
"There's a serial killer operating in California," I said quietly. "Not publicly acknowledged because the evidence is circumstantial. Cases spread across years, different jurisdictions, no obvious connections. But the signature is there."
I pulled up the encrypted files on my laptop, showing her the crime scene comparisons without the graphic details. Three other cases with similar staging, similar victimology, similar lack of forensic evidence.
"Miranda's case matches this pattern. The positioning, the lack of forced entry suggesting she knew her killer or was deceived into letting them in, the complete absence of usable evidence. It's too consistent to be coincidence."
Lorelei stared at the screen, processing. The System tracked her emotional response in real-time.
[ **ANALYZING: LORELEI RESPONSE** ]
[ **HOPE MARKERS: 67%** ]
[ **FEAR: 43%** ]
[ **DETERMINATION: RISING** ]
[ **TRUST LEVEL: 51% → 68%** ]
"You think my sister was killed by a serial killer," she said slowly. "And nobody knows."
"Nobody's connected the cases officially. The killer is careful, intelligent, operates across wide geographic areas with long cooling-off periods. It's nearly impossible to track."
"Nearly." She looked at me. "But not impossible."
"Not impossible."
"Can you..." She stopped, started again. "Through CBI, can you investigate this?"
This was the moment. The offer I'd been building toward.
"Not officially. Without hard evidence linking the cases, I can't open a formal investigation. But I can look into it quietly. Research the patterns, check for new cases, build a profile." I met her eyes. "With your help. You knew Miranda better than any file. You might remember details that seem insignificant but could be crucial."
Lorelei's eyes watered. She set the laptop aside and moved closer.
"You'd do that? Investigate my sister's murder, knowing it might go nowhere?"
"Because you deserve answers. And because I think I can find them."
The Lie Probability Gauge activated on my own statement.
[ **ANALYZING: OWN AUTHENTICITY** ]
[ **LIE PROBABILITY: 12%** ]
[ **GENUINE BELIEF IN ABILITY TO HELP: 88%** ]
[ **ROMANTIC MOTIVATION: PRESENT BUT NOT PRIMARY** ]
She kissed me.
Not grateful, not desperate—genuine. Her hands cupped my face, and the kiss was intense, honest, carrying five years of grief and the first real hope she'd felt since Miranda died.
When she pulled away, her expression had changed. Softer but determined.
"Thank you," she whispered. "For caring. For trying. For... everything."
The System chimed softly, new text appearing in my peripheral vision.
[ **NEW SKILL UNLOCKED: INFLUENCE METRONOME** ]
[ **TRIGGERED BY: SUCCESSFULLY MANAGING EMOTIONALLY COMPLEX CONVERSATION** ]
[ **FUNCTION: TRACKS CONVERSATIONAL CONTROL AND SOCIAL DYNAMICS** ]
[ **ACCURACY: 68% ±12%** ]
[ **MEASURES: TOPIC STEERING, EMOTIONAL INFLUENCE, PERSUASION SUCCESS** ]
[ **ENERGY: 54/100** ]
"Great. Another tool for manipulating people. Just what I needed."
But even as the cynical thought formed, I knew the truth. I'd wanted to help Lorelei before I'd known about the System's potential rewards. The skill was a side effect, not the motivation.
We spent the rest of the evening on the couch, talking through Miranda's life. Lorelei shared memories—her sister's favorite restaurant, the way she organized her apartment, friends she'd mentioned, colleagues she'd liked or disliked. Details a case file would never capture.
I took notes, mental and written, building a fuller picture of Miranda Martins. Not just a victim in crime scene photos, but a person. Someone who'd mattered, whose loss had rippled through lives.
By the time Lorelei left around midnight, the foundation was set. We were partners now—not just romantically, but investigatively. She trusted me with her deepest pain, and I'd promised to help carry it.
The door closed behind her, and I sat in my quiet apartment, processing.
[ **RELATIONSHIP PROGRESS: LORELEI MARTINS** ]
[ **TRUST LEVEL: 74% (MAJOR INCREASE)** ]
[ **ROMANTIC ATTACHMENT: DEEPENING** ]
[ **EMOTIONAL VULNERABILITY: SHARED** ]
[ **PARTNERSHIP ESTABLISHED: MIRANDA INVESTIGATION** ]
[ **PROFILE GENERATOR ACCURACY ON LORELEI: 76%** ]
[ **ENERGY: 52/100** ]
I pulled up Miranda's case file again, studying the crime scene photos with fresh eyes. Red John had done this. Had killed Miranda Martins five years ago, and would eventually try to recruit her sister through manipulating that grief.
But I was here now. Positioned between Lorelei and that future, armed with fragmented knowledge and a System that grew stronger every day.
The question was whether it would be enough.
My phone buzzed. Text from Jane: Saw your car at your apartment complex tonight. Date went well, I assume? You looked very serious when she left. Everything okay?
I stared at the message. He'd been watching. Not maliciously—Jane didn't do malice—but with that endless curiosity that made privacy impossible.
Everything's fine. And stop stalking me.
I prefer the term 'concerned colleague.' Sleep well, Colen.
I turned off the lights and went to bed, but sleep came slow. Too many threads pulling tight—Lorelei's trust, Miranda's murder, Jane's observation, Red John's shadow looming over everything.
The System provided one final update before I drifted off.
[ **QUEST PROGRESS: PREVENT LORELEI'S RED JOHN RECRUITMENT** ]
[ **STATUS: 43% COMPLETE** ]
[ **PARTNERSHIP ESTABLISHED: SUCCESS** ]
[ **NEXT MILESTONE: INVESTIGATE MIRANDA'S CASE** ]
[ **WARNING: RED JOHN AWARENESS UNKNOWN** ]
[ **PROCEED WITH CAUTION** ]
Tomorrow, I'd start really digging into Miranda's murder. Tonight, I'd let myself feel the weight of what I'd promised.
And hope to God I could actually deliver.
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!