Chapter 32: Thanksgiving
My parents called from Tokyo at 6 AM on Thanksgiving to announce they wouldn't be home until January.
"Business opportunity, Steve. Very important. You understand."
"Yeah. I understand." I understand you've never been parents. Just people who made me and then left.
"There's money in your account for food. Don't burn the house down."
They hung up.
I stared at the phone, then made a decision.
Called Joyce. "How many people can you feed for Thanksgiving?"
"Steve? What—"
"I'm hosting. My house. Everyone who matters. You, Will, Jonathan. Hopper and El. The Party. Nancy, Barb. Robin, Eddie, Chrissy. Your boyfriend Bob. Everyone."
Silence. Then Joyce's voice, thick with emotion: "Steve, you don't have to—"
"I want to. My parents aren't here. Yours is small. I've got space and kitchen and need something to feel grateful for. Say yes."
"Yes. God, yes. What do you need?"
"Just bring people. I'll handle food."
I'd never cooked Thanksgiving dinner. Didn't matter. I'd fought an interdimensional monster. Cooking turkey couldn't be harder.
Turns out cooking turkey was harder.
Chrissy found me at noon, sweating over recipes, kitchen looking like war zone.
"What are you doing?"
"Hosting Thanksgiving. It's going great." The turkey was still frozen. The recipe said "thaw for 24 hours." I'd given it six. "This is fine."
"This is a disaster." She rolled up sleeves. "Okay. First: run cold water over the turkey. Second: we're making backup ham. Third: you're on vegetable duty while I salvage this."
"I can cook—"
"Steve, I love you, but you're a fighter, not a chef. Let me help."
Robin arrived an hour later with Eddie, both carrying groceries.
"Heard you're attempting domestic tasks," Robin said. "Came to prevent disaster."
"I have it under control."
"You have panic under control. Cooking is questionable."
Eddie sprawled in my living room. "Dude, your house is massive. How is it always empty?"
"Parents travel. A lot." Understatement of the century.
"Their loss. More room for us."
People arrived in waves. Joyce and Will first, carrying green bean casserole. Jonathan with cranberry sauce. Hopper with turkey—already cooked, because he'd correctly predicted my incompetence.
"Figured you'd need backup," Hopper said, setting the bird on counter.
"I had it handled."
"You had chaos handled. This is dinner."
El entered quietly, overwhelmed by people and noise. I guided her to the living room, showed her the TV.
"You can hide here if it's too much."
"Is it always this loud?"
"Family usually is."
The Party arrived together, arguing about D&D. Mike, Dustin, Lucas, Max—chaotic and perfect. They immediately claimed the basement for campaign planning.
Nancy and Barb came last, Barb moving carefully but present. Nancy hugged me at the door.
"Thank you for this."
"For what?"
"For reminding us we're alive. That we get to celebrate."
"Everyone deserves Thanksgiving."
Barb smiled. "Even people who almost died in alternate dimensions?"
"Especially them."
Bob Newby arrived with Joyce, carrying pumpkin pie and nervous energy.
"Steve. Thanks for including me. Joyce talks about you constantly."
"Good things, I hope."
"Hero things. Brave things." Bob extended his hand. I shook it, feeling wrong-footed.
This man dies in eleven months. Torn apart by demo-dogs while saving everyone. And I don't know how to prevent it.
"Just did what anyone would do."
"Most people wouldn't storm a government facility," Bob said cheerfully. "But Joyce says you're special."
Different. Not special. Different.
I watched Bob interact with Will—gentle, patient, genuinely interested in the kid's drawings. Everything Joyce needed after Lonnie's abandonment.
And doomed. So completely doomed.
Maybe this time I can change it. Maybe Bob's death isn't fixed. Maybe—
But the fragmented memories suggested otherwise. Every attempt to save Bob created worse outcomes. As if the universe demanded his sacrifice.
"You okay, son?" Bob asked, noticing my stare.
"Yeah. Just... be careful out there. Hawkins is weirder than it looks."
"Weird how?"
Alternate dimensions. Monsters. Government conspiracies. Your death in eleven months.
"Just weird. Stay safe."
Bob laughed. "I'll try. RadioShack manager isn't exactly dangerous work."
It's not the work that kills you. It's the heroism.
Dinner was chaos—beautiful, loud, family chaos.
Seventeen people crammed around tables I'd pushed together in the dining room. Food covering every surface. Conversations overlapping. Laughter genuine.
El sat between Hopper and Mike, learning to say grace when Joyce insisted.
"What we're grateful for," Joyce prompted gently.
El looked around the table. "Friends. Family. Being safe."
"Will?" Joyce prompted.
"Being home. Being alive." Will glanced at me. "Having people who don't give up."
Down the line. The Party listing things—D&D, friends, Steve's basement. Nancy and Barb grateful for survival. Jonathan for his brother. Robin for weirdness being normalized.
Eddie: "Grateful King Steve turned out to be actual king instead of asshole."
"Eloquent," I muttered.
When it reached me, I looked at the assembled group. Found family. Broken and scarred and alive.
"I'm grateful I got to meet all of you. That I was here when you needed help. That we're together."
Hopper raised his glass. "To survival."
"To family," Joyce added.
We ate. Talked. Existed in peace.
Bob told dad jokes that made everyone groan. Eddie and Robin debated music with passion. The Party argued campaign strategy. Hopper and Joyce exchanged looks that suggested more than friendship. Nancy and Barb laughed genuinely for the first time in weeks.
El watched everything with quiet wonder.
This. This was worth fighting for. Worth bleeding for. Worth the nightmares and corruption and pain.
After dinner, we gathered in living room. Fireplace lit, November darkness outside, warmth inside.
"I need to say something," Joyce said, standing. Voice shaking but determined. "Steve Harrington saved my son. Saved Barb. Risked his life without hesitation. I don't know how to thank someone for that."
"You don't have to—"
"Let me finish." Tears streaming. "You gave me back the most important thing in my world. If there's anything you ever need, anything at all, you call. Understood?"
Nancy stood. "You saved my best friend. The bravest thing I've ever seen."
Hopper nodded, gruff. "You're a good kid, Harrington. Better than most adults I know."
El moved to my side, hugged me. "Brother," she whispered. "You're my brother."
Mike stepped forward reluctantly. "I was wrong about you. You're actually... pretty cool."
"High praise from Mike Wheeler," I managed through tight throat.
"You're the ultimate paladin," Dustin declared. "Like, literal D&D hero come to life."
Lucas: "Thanks for training us. For taking us seriously."
The gratitude continued. Each person sharing their piece. The weight of it crushing and uplifting simultaneously.
"We all saved each other," I said finally. "That's what family does. That's all I ever wanted—people willing to fight for each other."
Bob raised his glass last. "To Steve. To bravery. To doing what's right."
We drank. Talked late into night. Slowly people left—The Party picked up by parents, Nancy driving Barb home, Robin and Eddie heading out.
Chrissy stayed, helped clean, held me when exhaustion hit.
"You created something beautiful today."
"Just dinner."
"No. Family. You built family from broken pieces."
She was right. Looking at photos Robin had taken—everyone laughing, eating, together—I'd built something worth protecting.
I went to bed grateful. Content. Happy.
The nightmare hit at 3 AM.
Not fragmented images this time. Clear. Focused. Direct.
The Mind Flayer manifested in dream-space—vast shadow creature, intelligence beyond comprehension, attention focused entirely on me.
You, it said. Voice like thunder and ice and wrong. You hurt my vessel. Took my prey. You're different, traveler. I see echoes of other paths. Other attempts. You've done this before.
I tried waking. Couldn't. Trapped in nightmare.
You think you've won. Saved the children. Closed the gate. Killed my scout.
The shadow creature pressed closer. Suffocating.
But I'm patient. I've existed since before your species evolved. I'll exist after it ends. And I remember you now. Your scent. Your soul. Your interference.
Its attention pinned me like insect.
When I return—and I will return—I'll be ready. I'll adapt. I'll account for the variable called Steve Harrington. And this time, you won't take my vessels. You won't close my gates. You won't win.
Reality twisted. I saw Halloween 1984. Will's possession. The tunnels spreading. Bob Newby dying in the lab, torn apart while I watched helplessly.
Some deaths are inevitable, little traveler. Some prices must be paid. You can't save everyone.
The nightmare released me.
I woke screaming. Chrissy held me, whispering reassurance. But the Mind Flayer's words echoed.
You can't save everyone.
I'd heard that before. In fragmented memories. In other timelines. Every attempt to save Bob created worse outcomes.
As if his death was fixed point. Necessary sacrifice. Price for everyone else's survival.
"Steve?" Chrissy's voice, concerned. "What did you dream?"
"Nothing. Just nightmares."
Lies. All lies. But necessary lies.
I held her and tried not to think about next Halloween. About Bob's fate. About whether some deaths truly were inevitable.
The Mind Flayer was patient. It was coming back.
And it knew me now.
That changed everything.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0