The narrator recounted, "Angelica and Joseph performed 'What Are You Doing New Year's Eve' together at the Romania Theater, competing with all the other acts that evening. Megan was in the audience, recording their act just in case Angelica or Joseph did anything unusual." Joseph accompanied on piano while Angelica perched atop the instrument. She began singing solo before Joseph took over after her verse. Angelica sang another section alone, after which they both joined voices to conclude the song. Once they finished, the audience erupted in applause. Angelica called out, "Thank you, Transylvania; goodnight." Megan then ended the recording and kept the tape for herself.
The narrator stated, "As the clouds dispersed, the full moon emerged. Upon its appearance, Joseph's necklace emitted a green glow as he bowed alongside Angelica, and his hands became covered with fur. Observing the transformation of his hands into paws, Joseph concealed them within his pockets." Angelica commented, "They admire us, Joseph." Joseph responded, "Indeed, but I must depart immediately." He promptly exited backstage, with Angelica attempting to intervene. She called after him, "Joseph, please wait." The narrator continued, "Angelica proceeded backstage in search of Joseph but was unable to locate him. Megan, growing concerned, also entered the area but similarly did not find Joseph. However, they observed that the door had been left open. Both Angelica and Megan looked outside but saw no sign of Joseph. Suddenly, they heard a howl, which Angelica immediately recognized."
Angelica called her friends on her cell phone and said, "Howling downtown. You know what that means." On the other end, Matthew responded, "Yep, we'll be on the lookout." After hanging up, Angelica went back inside, tied a backstage sheet around her neck, and transformed herself into a bat. She flew out the window and spotted Joseph loose in Transylvania. When Joseph saw Angelica, he tried to chase her off, but she refused to leave him alone. Joseph searched everywhere for people but found no one; his presence sparked panic, causing everyone in Transylvania to run home and hide from him. Despite not finding anyone in town, Joseph saw an entire legion of vampire bats heading his way. Suddenly uneasy, Joseph bolted, but as he ran, the bats transformed into vampires and surrounded him. Joseph managed to jump out of the circle, accidentally smashing someone's car before escaping unseen, with the vampires hot on his trail.
Matthew attempted to shoot Joseph with a net gun, but Joseph dodged just in time. Using his claws, Joseph cut through a light post and took Matt out of action. Raven called out, "I'll help Matt. You all go after the werewolf." Transforming into a wolf, Carolyn tried to match Joseph's speed, but he growled, grabbed her tail, spun her around, and threw her at Raven, knocking them both down at once. Angelica intervened by kicking Joseph, sending him crashing into a building. She then drew a gun loaded with silver bullets and aimed it at him. Despite being in werewolf form, Joseph recognized Angelica. Acting quickly, Joseph slashed a rope, bringing a chandelier down on Angelica.
Afterward, Angelica inadvertently discharged the firearm, but the shot did not hit its intended target. Maddy and Chris broke into the building as Joseph broke out. Chris discreetly placed a tracking device on Joseph and utilized it to monitor his destination. Maddy and Chris went downtown with Joseph, carrying silver with the intention of killing him. When the tracer died out, they found Joseph at a dead end. Maddy and Chris closed in on him with their silver necklace and belt buckle, but Joseph scaled a wall to the roof of the building, hit a drainpipe down when he got to the top, and knocked Maddy and Chris unconscious. Joseph rushed toward home, hoping to get there before sunrise, but he didn't make it in time.
The following account, as narrated by the storyteller, covers the period from "upon morning's arrival" until Joseph finds Angelica and Megan awaiting his awakening.
The following account, as narrated by the storyteller, covers the period from "upon morning's arrival" until Joseph finds Angelica and Megan awaiting his awakening.
The narrator recounted that, upon morning's arrival, Joseph reverted to his usual self in the village, his clothing torn from prior events. Angelica subsequently appeared, collected Joseph, and carried him home. On their return, Megan invited Angelica to join Joseph on the sofa. When Joseph regained consciousness, he noticed both Angelica and Megan present and awaiting his awakening. Joseph expressed, "Oh, I'm home. I had the strangest dream last night." Angelica responded, "Well, it's over now."
While seated on the sofa, Joseph glanced at Angelica, struggling to comprehend her intentions from the previous evening. Megan then applied an ice pack to Joseph's head to alleviate his discomfort. Joseph, recalling troubling memories, became upset with Angelica for allegedly attempting to harm him, which caused the jewel around his neck to emit a red glow. Seeking composure, Joseph retrieved his guitar and performed an original piece. In response, Angelica remarked, "That is not the song we played last night." Joseph clarified, "I am aware; this composition is my own." Angelica replied appreciatively, "Impressive, Joseph. I genuinely enjoy your music—as well as your company." As Joseph began to sing, Angelica recognized the lyrics and joined in. Meanwhile, Megan, overhearing their performance, found the melody appealing. When they concluded, Joseph placed his guitar aside and held Angelica's hands.
The narrator recounted, "On that evening, Joseph performed on stage at Bird Karaoke, singing the song he had previously sung to Angelica on his porch. Angelica, Megan, and the audience observed as Joseph began, and Megan subsequently joined him on stage, with both singing together." During their performance, Angelica rose to join them, followed by members of the audience who took turns singing individually until the entire crowd participated. The narrator continued, "Upon completion, the audience applauded Joseph and Megan, who then proceeded backstage while Angelica prepared for her performance." Angelica sang into the microphone as the audience waved their arms in synchrony. Her song expressed affection for someone she admired, and Joseph returned her smile. Angelica returned the gesture as she continued her performance. At the conclusion, the audience applauded Angelica.
The narrator explained, "At the same time, Megan was having a video chat with Kayla." During their conversation, Kayla remarked, "I saw your video of your brother and looked into it." Megan asked, "And?" Kayla replied, "He's either deeply infatuated or under some spell. When did this begin?" Megan took a moment to think and answered, "Now that you mention it, it started right after Angelica beat us at Bird Karaoke's sing-off. The next day, he bought a necklace and got sick when he wore it." Kayla clarified, "You mean the necklace he's wearing in the video?" Megan confirmed, "Yes." Kayla suggested, "Let's look into this. I'll check the library for information about the necklace, and you should find out more about Angelica."
According to the narrator, after their call, a cloaked figure saw Megan through her window but left before the rain began. This person then contacted Angelica to alert her that Megan was investigating her.