I tried, I really tried.
I used everything I had.
I tried everything I could think of.
Defend the mansion.
Evacuate the mansion.
Ambush Subaru.
Create a diversion.
Everything ended the same way.
Subaru anticipated anything I could come up with.
None of my plans worked.
I failed again and again.
My return by death was set after Garfiel's escape, when Clind had already gone out to look for him.
Too late to modify the scenario and save the strongest piece.
No, even if I could keep Clind, the outcome wouldn't change.
Regulus and Roswaal were still there. I learned a few things about them.
For example, I understood that Roswaal joined Subaru not out of obedience, but out of ambition.
Flashback.
Roswaal and Echidna's presence in the mansion implied an almost inevitable encounter between them, which happened in one of the many loops I wasted trying to stop Subaru.
"Teacher..."
For a moment, Roswaal's expression had turned nostalgic upon seeing Echidna, his eyes clouded by the veil of memory. However, remembering that this wasn't the same person, his gaze grew cold and he shook his head.
"No, you aren't the original Echidna. You're a product of her greed, an echo of her will. My teacher had a sparkle in her eyes, a genuine smile. You only imitate human emotions, don't you?"
Echidna looked at him with a calm smile and replied condescendingly.
"Hmm, and are you the original Roswaal, or just a ghost of the past? The enthusiastic young man from 400 years ago is no longer reflected in your eyes. You've lost your identity for the sake of a mission you're incapable of fulfilling."
Roswaal blinked, irritated.
"I haven't lost anything. I've left behind what I don't need. And I assure you, I'm going to bring back the real Echidna."
"You're wrong about that too. The Echidna of your memories is an idealized version. Truth be told, you never truly got to know her, did you? According to my inherited memories of her, you were just a talented apprentice, a potential helper, but nothing more. Even if that Echidna were still alive, she still wouldn't look twice at you. In fact, her attention would be completely focused on a certain person..."
Echidna's eyes drifted toward me with a half-smile creeping onto her lips, like a subtle tease.
Realizing what she meant, Roswaal narrowed his eyes.
"I don't care. My only interest is bringing her back and making her happy. What happens to me after that is irrelevant."
Roswaal raised a hand and blue fire filled the room.
End of Flashback.
I also realized that while both were archbishops, Regulus wasn't working with Subaru: he was working for Subaru.
I knew it the moment that albino bastard laid his eyes on Emilia.
Flashback.
While ravaging the mansion, Regulus caught me trying to flee with Emilia and company.
"Oh? What a pure and modest beauty."
Regulus's eyes gleamed upon seeing her and his mouth twisted into a wicked smile.
He walked toward Emilia and reached his hand out to her.
"You, I've decided you will be my new wife."
"Forget it."
Regulus stopped dead in his tracks when he heard Subaru's cold voice.
The Japanese boy had appeared in the room like a ghost, stepping between Emilia and the Archbishop of Greed.
"What are you..."
"She's mine, so stop looking at her."
Regulus looked surprised for a moment, but then his face distorted into a furious grimace.
"Listen to me well... Who do you think you are to give me orders? Even if that old witch pampers you, you're nothing more than the new kid! And I am the most powerful archbishop! No one is above me! I won't tolerate you disrespecting me with your insolence anymore!"
The albino lashed out at Subaru, making a gesture to shove the air destructively, but Subaru walked right through the attack, reached Regulus, and delivered a punch that sent him crashing down into a sitting position.
"I'm sick of hearing your bullshit."
"..."
Regulus was as surprised as I was when he touched his reddened cheek and noticed his lip was split, blood welling from the wound.
"You... How?"
Instead of giving him explanations, Subaru grabbed him by the neck and lifted him up, looking at him with contempt.
"Emilia is mine. I don't care what you want to do with the others, but you don't touch her. If you aren't capable of obeying such a simple order, I'll have to get rid of you."
"He just ignored Regulus's authority, just like... Don't tell me!"
Reid and the Doppelgangers immediately came to mind, but I quickly dismissed the red-headed swordsman from the equation. I realized something crucial: if I had stolen Subaru's existence, it meant I currently had his body and soul. He must have been a fragment that broke off independently, just like my Doppelgangers.
And what else did they have in common with him? The ability to ignore authorities: not cutting through them, but attacking right through them or directly nullifying them.
"Tsk, damn it... This is unforgivable, an insult to my pride, to my dignity..."
Regulus gritted his teeth to keep from saying anything else, knowing he could die if he continued opposing Subaru. For the first time, the Archbishop of Greed had to lower his head and submit.
That would have been very satisfying to see under other circumstances.
Finally, Subaru let go of Regulus.
"Now do your job and kill everyone while Leandro can't do absolutely anything to stop it."
Reluctantly, Regulus obeyed.
End of Flashback.
Fleeing was impossible. Fighting was useless.
I had run out of options. Subaru had cornered me in checkmate.
RBD was no longer an advantage; it was a torture.
Of course, I knew I still had a way out.
After all, Satella wouldn't set the save point at a point of no return.
However, I knew I wouldn't like that possibility.
I would never leave on my own; I would never abandon my friends.
It was already too late to retreat.
But I couldn't save anyone either.
I couldn't even save myself.
I had lost. For the first time, my defeat was absolute.
Subaru wasn't even trying to recover his identity.
He was toying with me. He wanted to break me.
He murdered everyone in front of me, sometimes faster, sometimes slower.
He tortured them slowly or drove them to despair.
He forced me to watch as he killed them.
He even made them kill each other.
Flashback.
"Otto, you have to kill Leandro right now, or I'll kill Frederica," Subaru said with a smile while holding Frederica, pressing a knife against her neck.
"No... You can't force me to choose between them..."
"Hurry up, my hand is starting to slip"—the knife sank partially into Frederica's flesh, making her bleed.
"STOP IT!"
Otto screamed with tears in his eyes, looking desperately between Frederica and me.
"I can't... No, please don't..."
"Otto!" I yelled with anger. "Stop hesitating! Just kill me already!"
Otto cried harder as he raised the revolver in my direction.
"I'm sorry, Leandro... Please forgive me..."
He prepared to pull the trigger, but at that exact moment, his head exploded. The sound of scattering flesh was accompanied by metallic chains dragging a spiked iron ball.
Seeing that, I could only gasp in frustration.
"Why did you do it, Rem...?"
Rem looked at me with sadness as she gathered her weapon.
"If you die, my life will have no meaning"—she glanced to the side—"I'm sorry, Frederica."
The blonde had let out a piercing scream when she saw Otto die. Subaru let out a sadistic laugh and kicked her, throwing her to the ground next to the headless corpse.
"Since you're willing to decide who lives and who dies, choose between these two, Rem!" Subaru exclaimed, teleporting inexplicably and grabbing Petra.
"No! Let me go!" The girl panicked and thrashed, but couldn't break free.
"You're a disgusting scum"—Rem spat her hatred toward Subaru, glaring daggers at him.
"Such a sharp tongue you have"—Subaru raised his eyebrows and looked at me—"Must hurt when she sucks on it, right?"
Rem didn't wait for an answer from me or another taunt from Subaru: she lunged at him, trying to pull him away from Petra and land a good hit in the process.
But she passed right through both of them as if they were holograms.
"Oh, Rem. Didn't you hear me when I gave you the options? Whatever, I'll take that as you preferring to save Frederica."
Subaru tapped Petra's head with his finger, a subtle and completely non-violent movement. He let her go a second later and Petra ran into my arms. She reached me and buried her face in my chest, crying.
"Leandro, please do something! I'm so scared!"
I didn't know what to tell her. Better yet, I didn't know how to tell her that I couldn't do anything, that I had become completely useless.
Suddenly, she let go of me and stepped back.
"Eh?"
She seemed to notice something. At that moment, her eyes turned red and her nose began to bleed.
"I feel weird... Help me..."
Her eyes rolled back and she collapsed. She didn't die immediately: first, her body began to convulse and she let out a few groans as foam came out of her mouth, until finally the spasms stopped.
I stood still and watched her die slowly. I didn't do it out of indifference, but out of an immeasurable frustration and helplessness.
Frederica, who watched Otto and Petra die in the span of a minute, looked at me with an expression of pain and disappointment as she cried.
"You said you would protect us... Why are you letting us die?!"
"What a great question!" Subaru was clapping at the scene, delighted. "Aren't you going to answer her, Leandro?"
"..."
I couldn't. I didn't want to admit my incompetence out loud, because then I truly would have given up.
Seeing my conflicted expression, Subaru let out a delighted laugh.
"Look at you! Now that is pride!"
End of Flashback.
I no longer knew how many loops I had been trapped in this situation, but I did know I couldn't endure another useless death.
"Bleergh!"
I collapsed to the ground and threw up due to the unbearable sickness I felt. I had watched everyone die hundreds of times; every single one of those times I couldn't do anything for them.
"Think, think, think! There has to be something I can do!"
Then my mind drifted back to the idea of fleeing.
Maybe Subaru wouldn't bother torturing the others if I wasn't there to watch.
But nothing guaranteed he wouldn't kill them just to punish me for abandoning them.
"Do I even have another option...?"
I made a massive mental effort to come up with something.
And in the process, my brain unlocked a new memory. It used to happen at random moments, after killing a Doppelganger, but this time it wasn't very convenient.
In these new memories, I saw myself in the library of the Pleiades Watchtower, reading the Books of the Dead.
I had designed my own version of the Sacrament of the Immortal King, using those books as a base.
"Necromancer memories... Right now?"
If I had my powers, it wouldn't be a bad idea to bring back Reid Astrea, who could cut through Subaru's and Regulus's authority. But that wasn't an option.
"Leandro?! What's wrong?!"
Rem came running over upon hearing me vomit. She knelt beside me and lifted my head, observing my state with deep concern.
"The witch's scent has become very strong... Did that power activate again? Is there any danger?"
"Ah."
Seeing her was like flipping a switch. Suddenly, everything clicked.
The Necromancer's resurrection technique.
It didn't revive the dead.
It copied them.
Rem never came back.
The one taking her place was a copy.
"No... No, no, no, no, no!"
I recoiled in disgust, not from her, but from myself. Rem read my emotions perfectly, noticing the repulsion I was feeling.
"Leandro...?"
"Stay away!" I yelled and ran off. I couldn't look at her, I couldn't hear her voice or I would completely shatter.
Every step I took was exhausting, every second felt like an eternity. The air I breathed in desperation didn't fill the void in my chest.
Rem was dead. I never got her back, I only brought in a backup copy.
Outside the mansion, the world was quiet and silent, which amplified the sound of my gasps. I ran through the garden, as if I could physically run away from the guilt tearing me apart from the inside.
My pathetic attempt at escaping ended when I tripped over a rock and fell flat on my face. Still writhing in pain on the ground, I crawled like a worm, scratching the dirt hysterically while tears streamed from my eyes.
"DAMN IT! WHY?!"
"Why? Because you're an idiot."
A familiar shadow cast over me and mocked with a playful voice. I didn't have to raise my head to know it was Subaru.
Answering me, he continued: "Always making bad decisions, believing everything will turn out fine... Did you ever stop to think if what you were doing made any sense?"
"Stop it already..."
"You're a hypocrite for playing the hero now, when in all the previous timelines you dedicated yourself to destroying everything. Ha, you're so rotten that your own clones are trying to kill you."
I gritted my teeth in anger. I knew I couldn't harm him, much less in this state.
"WHAT THE HELL DO YOU WANT?!"
Subaru wasn't fazed by my scream. The light in his eyes was murky and cold.
"You already know. I want you to suffer, I want you to break slowly until there's nothing left. After that, I'll take what you took from me."
My fury quickly turned into a sense of defeat and bitterness.
"So you're going to keep doing this over and over?"
"Exactly. I have a lot of ideas to torture you. Have you seen Berserk? I could use Rem to recreate the Casca and Griffith scene, what do you think?"
Those words awakened a savage hatred inside me. I lunged to try and hit him, but as expected, I couldn't even touch him.
"Hajaja! I think I've already found your weak spot! I'm going to have so much fun making you watch that traitor degrade!"
"I WON'T ALLOW IT! EVEN IF I HAVE TO DIE A MILLION TIMES TO PREVENT IT, I WON'T LET YOU TOUCH HER!"
"Why do you care so much? Isn't she just a copy of the original, whom by the way, you couldn't save?"
Subaru continued mocking my attempts to hurt him physically. Even knowing it was useless to keep trying, I was so angry I couldn't stop myself.
"SHUT UP!"
My hysteria had reached the point where I could no longer speak. My mouth emitted a mix of growls and sobs while tears burst from my eyes in a constant stream.
Suddenly I tripped over my own feet and crashed to the ground.
"Haa... Ugh..."
"What a pathetic protagonist. Is this what you replaced me for? To be a good-for-nothing who falls under his own weight?"
Subaru's voice sounded distant from the depths of the misery I was sinking into. My sanity had reached its limit.
At that moment, I felt the pressure of hands touching my back and shoulders. I slowly turned my head, dazed but still conscious.
"Ah."
I saw myself, or rather, three versions of myself. They were the Hunter, the Swordsman, and the Necromancer.
All three stared at me intensely. They seemed to want to tell me something. Following their gazes, I realized they were pointing toward my abdomen.
Then I saw it: a faint purple glow burning inside me. It had been a long time since I last felt latent magic in my body.
Apparently, the wounds in my soul had begun to heal with the time that had passed since I woke up, even though technically it had happened only a few hours ago. However, since my soul was the only thing that didn't reset in the loops, RBD didn't affect my recovery.
"This energy is... Sloth's authority?"
The word clicked in my head.
Authority.
Archbishop.
Regulus.
Nullify.
Doppelganger.
Subaru.
It might not make much sense, but there is a very specific relationship between those words.
The authority reminded me of the archbishops, which in turn reminded me of the recent loop where Subaru nullified Regulus's authority, just like my Doppelgangers did with me.
If they can, I can too, right?
I looked at Subaru.
The problem was how to perform such a technique. Apparently, physical contact wasn't required: if I had to guess based on my experience, I would say activation depended on the distance to the target.
Subaru, who noticed the subtle shift in my expression of despair and madness, frowned.
"What's wrong with you now?"
"..."
I ignored him and closed my eyes, concentrating on evoking the memories of my Doppelgangers. They had learned to use that technique in their timelines. I just needed to search for those specific memories.
A few moments later, I opened my eyes.
"Got it."
"Eh? What are you talking about? Have you gone crazy already...? Oof!"
Subaru gasped as my fist sank into his stomach. His body twisted and he spat saliva onto my shoulder.
As if I had developed a sixth sense, I could now see and feel his authority, or rather, the witch factor residing inside him. Through that connection, I managed to block Subaru's access to that power.
"You..."
I didn't let him continue. My hand closed around his neck, pressing down with the force of a hydraulic press.
"Guh... Ajj..."
Subaru tried to struggle, but I didn't loosen my grip. I knew I had to kill him as quickly as possible, so I was trying to break his neck.
"Pfft..."
I thought he was trying to breathe, but he was actually laughing, even as his bones crunched in my hands.
"Do you think you can beat me with that trick?"
I was surprised to see him act so arrogant even when his life was in my hands. But then, Regulus and Roswaal appeared.
They weren't alone.
Roswaal was carrying Emilia with him. He wasn't holding her tightly, but he had a spell pointed straight at her head. On the other hand, Regulus was holding Rem by the neck with an annoyed expression.
"Shit, the girls! I didn't think of that!"
"I admit I went overboard with the time I took to play with you, since I didn't account for your powers returning sooner or later"—Subaru managed to speak despite the asphyxiation—"However, it was worth seeing you suffer and writhe in helplessness."
I narrowed my eyes. If I killed Subaru, the other two would kill Rem and Emilia. Besides, Subaru was also blocking my authority, which made attacking Regulus and Roswaal impossible. Furthermore, my powers hadn't recovered enough yet to fight them.
"I know what you're thinking"—Subaru said with a smile—"Why do you care so much? Well, I understand Emilia is important to you, but Rem has been dead for a long time: even if she died now, she's nothing more than a copy, so you can just make another one."
"Shut up!" I tensed when he said the words Rem shouldn't hear. Obviously, he did it on purpose to watch me suffer and wouldn't stop at any threat.
"Come on, don't play the sensitive guy now. As soon as you realized what she is, you felt disgusted and pushed her away. If you dropped the hypocrisy, you could kill me and end my plans right now. That coldness was what made you invincible in the other timelines, why are you pretending to be a decent person now, after everything you've done?"
He was right. The son of a bitch was right about me. I wasn't a good person and could never be one, but that didn't mean I was going to let my loved ones die just to get rid of my enemies. I had told Roswaal that I would never sacrifice my feelings, that I would never give up anything. If I became like him... or if I went back to being like before, like my versions from the other timelines, then there would no longer be any difference between my enemies and me.
"You don't know anything, cultist!" Rem shouted, glaring daggers at Subaru while struggling like a furious beast to break free from Regulus's grip. "Don't you dare use your dirty mouth to speak ill of Leandro!"
"Look, the copy of your dead slave defends you even after you treated her like trash. That is true love... and a severe lack of self-respect too, hahaha."
SMACK!
At that point, I was sick of hearing his bullshit, so I punched him right in the nose.
"Pfft!"—Although his nose was bleeding, he managed to let out another mocking chuckle—"That was very childish! You have to learn to deal with frustration without resorting to violence."
"Shut. The. Fuck. Up"—I said slowly and emphatically, containing my anger.
Subaru kept his smile and looked at me defiantly, knowing he had cornered me and that I had no other choice but to let him go.
"Tsk. Tell your dogs to let the girls go and I'll let you go."
"Pfft. HAHAHAHA!"
"What the hell is so funny?"
"When did I offer you a truce? I only told you that you can kill me and accept that they die as the price for getting rid of me. I never said I was giving up."
"What?!"
Subaru licked his lips, wiping away the blood that had dripped from his nose.
"If they die, you'll restart to save them. But even if you recover your powers, you still won't be able to prevent me from killing some of your friends. You can't protect them all."
"Son of a bitch!" I yelled, barely managing to hold back the urge to kill him.
"Like I said before, I want you to break, and I don't plan on stopping until I see you renounce your stupid, hypocritical moral code. If you want to win, you'll have to stoop to my level, but you're too proud to do it."
"No... I'm not going to do that"—I denied fiercely—"I'm going to defeat you by being myself."
"It's useless. You'll lose over and over, but no matter how many times you repeat it, you will never be able to beat me."
Just as the tension reached its peak, a supernatural presence filled the air with an ethereal, almost dreamlike sensation.
"You are being very reckless, Archbishop Natsuki."
Surrounded by a thin layer of fog, Pandora made her entrance.
