"What's the matter, Carlyle?"
The voice came from the other side of the door, smooth and amused and edged with something harder underneath. Carlyle knew that voice better than he knew his own. He'd heard it every day for four years. He heard it in his dreams.
"Are you calling for help?" Victor asked. "Again?"
Carlyle opened his eyes.
He was sitting on the floor in the corner of his room with his back against the wall and his knees pulled up, the way he'd been sitting for the last hour. Sweat was rolling down his face. His whole body ached like he'd run a marathon, and his hands, when he looked at them, were still glowing faintly at the fingertips, a pale, pearly white that was already fading.
He'd been so close. He'd felt it. Someone had almost heard him.
He wiped his face on his sleeve and pasted on a smile.
"What does it matter to you?" he called back. "Scared someone'll answer?"
The door opened.
It always looked strange to Carlyle when it opened, because for the first few seconds he couldn't see the man standing in it. The spell on the room did that. With the door open, the world outside his cell blurred and smeared like a watercolor left in the rain. It was only when the door swung shut again and the lock clicked that Victor came into focus, standing just inside it with his hands folded behind his back.
He wasn't a big man. That had surprised Carlyle once, back at the beginning, when he'd still been surprised by things. Victor was medium height and lean, with a straight back and a long, clever face lined deeply around the eyes and mouth. His hair was brown, swept back from a high forehead and going gray at the temples in two neat silver wings. His eyes were a pale, cool gray, the color of rain on a window. He wore a beautifully cut charcoal suit, not tan, never tan, with a silver pin on the lapel in the shape of a closed eye.
He looked like a history professor. Or a kindly grandfather. Or a man who had once, a long time ago, been very handsome and still remembered it.
He did not look like a monster. That was the worst part.
"Don't make me laugh, my boy," Victor said, and smiled. "No one will ever answer you."
"You never know." Carlyle levered himself off the floor and crossed to his bed, mostly so he'd have something to do with his body that wasn't shaking. "Someone will hear me. And they'll get me out of this cell."
"You can wish all you like." Victor walked to the little sink in the corner and ran one finger along its edge, inspecting it for dust. "But you're not leaving. Not ever."
Carlyle looked around the room. It wasn't much to look at. White walls. White floor. A narrow bed with a thin blanket. A sink and a toilet in one corner, half hidden behind a short partition. A single shelf with six books he'd read so many times their spines had cracked into white lines. A barred window, high up near the ceiling, that showed nothing but a square of electric light, because there was nothing on the other side of it but more concrete.
The only real color in the room was him. He'd caught his reflection in the steel mirror over the sink that morning, the way he did every morning, and felt the same small jolt of strangeness he always felt: a tall, rangy sixteen-year-old with a shock of fiery red hair that stuck up no matter what he did to it, freckles splashed across a long, sharp face, and bright blue eyes, so pale and clear they were almost silver. They looked, he always thought, like they belonged to somebody else.
He'd never known whose.
"Why am I still here?" he asked. "Why not just kill me and get it over with?"
"Because I need what's inside you." Victor turned from the sink and pushed a hand through his hair. "The power you're carrying. I need it to wake the demon queen."
"Then why haven't you done it?" Carlyle got off the bed again. He couldn't stay still. He walked right up to Victor, close enough to see the fine, pale scar that ran along his jawline. "You've had me here for four years. What are you waiting for?"
"For the others, my boy." Victor laughed. It was a warm, genuine laugh, and it made Carlyle's skin crawl. "I need the seven other elements to wake her. All eight together. And you," he tapped Carlyle once, gently, on the breastbone, "are going to help me find them."
"Why would I ever help you?" Carlyle didn't step back. "You're a manipulative, lying, creepy old jerk."
"Because I always get what I want," Victor said simply. "That's why."
There was a knock on the door.
"Sir?" A blurred shape in the doorway, sharpening as the door closed behind it. "Mr. Tempest needs you upstairs. It's about the other powers. He says they've found something."
"Ah. Thank you, Justin." Victor turned away from Carlyle without another glance, already straightening his cuffs. "I'm coming." At the door, he paused, and smiled over his shoulder. "I'll see you later, my boy."
"Have fun being someone's lackey, Victor," Carlyle called after him, and smiled sweetly.
The door opened. Victor blurred and was gone.
Justin stayed.
Justin Bay was the kind of person who looked like he'd been assembled out of spare parts from much nastier people. He was slight and wiry, not much taller than Carlyle, with a narrow, pointed face that made him look about twenty, even though Carlyle had overheard enough over the years to know he was well into his thirties. His dark-honey hair was cut in a sharp undercut, the long top slicked back. His hazel eyes were swirled with gold and green and brown, and they were always, always laughing at something. He wore a tannish brown suit like all of Victor's people, but he wore it badly on purpose, the jacket open, the tie loose, the sleeves shoved up to show the tattoos on his forearms. Shadows. Twisting black shapes that sometimes, if you looked at them too long, seemed to move.
"So," Justin said, leaning against the wall. "Are you having fun yet?"
"Always," Carlyle said. "You?"
"You know me. I'm always having fun."
"Yeah. Being somebody's sidekick." Carlyle sat back down on his bed. "Must be a blast. Fetching people. Running errands. Do you get dental?"
Justin's smile slipped, just a little. "You think you're so funny, Carlyle."
"I know I'm so funny. It's the only thing in here I'm sure of." Carlyle stretched out on his back on the thin mattress and laced his fingers behind his head. "So what do you want, Justin? Just came to annoy me?"
"No." Justin's smile came back, wider. "I just like watching you be a prisoner. It's relaxing. Like watching fish in a tank."
Carlyle stared at the ceiling. He'd heard things, over the last few days. Whispers through the door. Raised voices in the hall. A woman screaming and screaming in the cell down the corridor. Victor's people were rattled. Something had happened out in the world, something bad for them, and Carlyle had pieced together enough of it to make a guess.
He shouldn't say it. He knew he shouldn't say it.
He'd been in this room for four years. He said it anyway.
"Where's your twin sister, Justin?" he asked lightly. "Oh, wait. I forgot. She got her throat slashed."
Justin went still.
The shadows on his forearms writhed.
"Don't you ever," Justin said, very softly, "talk about Ariel like that."
"Did I hurt your little feelings?" Carlyle put on a high, babyish voice. "Did I make the bad man sad?"
For a second he thought Justin might actually kill him. He could see it in his face. The shadows were crawling up past his elbows now, black and oily, reaching toward his throat.
Then the door opened again, and a voice said, "Oh, are you two fighting? Can I watch?"
Karen Bay was the youngest of them, and somehow the worst. She was tiny, maybe five feet tall in her sensible black heels, with a heart-shaped face sprinkled with freckles and big, round, innocent hazel eyes, the Bay eyes, under thick dark lashes. Her dark brown hair was twisted up into two neat buns on top of her head like a cartoon panda. She was probably in her early twenties, but she had the high, sweet, lilting voice of a little girl, and she used it to say the most horrible things Carlyle had ever heard.
"He was talking about Ariel," Justin said tightly.
"Oh." Karen turned those big eyes on Carlyle and pouted. "That wasn't nice, Carlyle. Ariel was my sister. I could drown you, you know. Right here. In your own sink." She tilted her head. "Wouldn't that be funny?"
Things got worse after that.
They always did, when the two of them were together.
It was a long time before the room was quiet again.
Carlyle lay curled on his side on the bed, facing the wall. He wasn't hurt badly. They never hurt him badly. Victor didn't like it when they damaged the merchandise. But his ribs ached, and his lip was split, and he was so tired. So tired that the edges of the room were going soft and gray.
He closed his eyes.
He reached down inside himself, past the ache and the tiredness and the fear, to the place where the light lived. It was always there. A small, steady, pearly glow, like a candle in a window. It was the only thing they'd never been able to take from him.
He held it in his cupped hands, in his mind, and he lifted it, and he pushed. Out. Away. Through the walls and the floor and the concrete and the miles. The way you'd throw a message in a bottle into the sea.
Help me, he thought, into the dark. Please. I know someone can hear me. Help me.
Nothing.
He'd been doing this for four years. Every single night. Nothing ever answered.
Help me, he thought again. I know you can hear me. Please.
And then, impossibly, faint and far away and startled:
Who are you?
Carlyle's eyes flew open.
He was still lying on his bed. The white room was still around him. But the voice was in his head, as clear as if someone were lying right beside him, whispering in his ear. A girl's voice. Sleepy and confused and a little bit cranky.
And are you okay?
He squeezed his eyes shut again. He grabbed at the light inside him with both hands and held on so tight it hurt.
You answered, he thought. His whole chest was burning. You answered me. Oh my God. You actually answered. Please, please help me.
How am I supposed to help you, the girl said, if I don't even know who you are? Or where you are? A pause. Or where I am, honestly. Why is it so dark?
I'm in your head, Carlyle told her. And you're asleep. It's okay. I think you're dreaming.
Great. Cool. That's so much better. But she didn't sound scared, exactly. She sounded curious. So who are you?
My name is Carlyle.
I'm Katherine.
They talked.
He didn't know for how long. Time felt different in the dark between them. He told her about the white room, and the door that turned the world to watercolor, and the man in the charcoal suit. He told her about the light inside him, and how Victor wanted it, and how Victor wanted seven more powers just like it to wake something terrible. And she told him about a basement full of weapons, and a sword made by an angel, and a goldfish named Sir Swims-a-Lot.
Eight powers, she said, slowly. Fairy, Sea, Earth, Fire, Wind, Light, Dark, Spirit. We've got four. We're looking for the others. A pause. Wait. You have light powers?
Yeah.
I have Dark. Her voice in his head had gone strange. Hushed. I think that's why I can hear you. Light and dark. They're supposed to find each other. They balance each other.
Carlyle didn't know what to say to that. He'd never balanced anything in his life.
But he felt it. Something pulling, warm and steady, from very far away. Like a hand reaching out in the dark and closing around his.
Where are you? Katherine asked. Tell me where you are.
I don't know. Underground. Somewhere with glass. He was starting to fade. He could feel it, his grip on the light slipping, the edges of her voice going fuzzy. Victor. His name is Victor. He has people. The Bays. And there's someone upstairs called Tempest. I'm sorry, I can't—I'm losing—
Hang on. Carlyle, hang on, don't go—
Find me, he thought, with the very last of his strength. Please. Find me.
I will. Her voice, small and fierce and fading. I promise. I'll find you, Carlyle. I swear.
The light went out of his hands.
Carlyle opened his eyes to the white room and the humming bulb and the cracked spines of his six books.
He was alone.
But for the first time in four years, he didn't feel like it.
