Cherreads

Chapter 25 - IS THIS A CHALLENGE?

The oven timer buzzed sharply, and Aiden pulled the last tray of cookies free. Golden-brown, steaming slightly as cold air met their heat, they filled the classroom with a warm, sweet aroma.

He placed them on cooling racks, brushing a smudge of flour from his apron. The soft, sugary scent seemed to cling to him, a reminder of mundane comfort in a life otherwise riddled with complications.

Angela leaned over the tray, eyes wide, taking in the sight and smell. "Ooh, they look amazing. I thought we were going to bomb this."

Haley grinned, brushing back a braid that had loosened in her excitement. "That's because Aiden did all the work. I nearly dropped the first tray."

"I just followed the recipe," Aiden replied, fingers dusted with flour. "Timing helps too."

Nearby students drifted closer, drawn by the scent and the sight of perfection. A blackened sheet of charred chocolate discs on a neighboring station only made Aiden's cookies shine in contrast.

"Wow," one guy muttered, glancing enviously. "You guys crushed it."

Angela nudged him playfully. "Tall, calm, and you can bake? Dangerous combo."

Haley smirked, tilting her head toward Aiden. "Forget Nate from basketball. If I can snag someone who bakes and looks like that? Why bother?"

Angela giggled, shaking her head. "You're shameless."

Aiden shook his head faintly, a subtle smile tugging at his lips as he reached for bags to divide the cookies. Another ding from the oven timer called him to remove the final batch, perfectly golden and sweetly fragrant. He could feel the heat lingering on his skin as he worked, a constant reminder of how ordinary yet comforting this moment felt.

"So," Haley said, leaning a little closer as she helped, "are you going to the party this weekend?"

Aiden raised an eyebrow. "Maybe. Haven't decided yet."

"Well," she shrugged, trying to sound casual. "If you don't want to go alone, I wouldn't mind tagging along."

Her smile was bright, confident. Bold. A little too bold.

Before he could respond, the sharp, familiar voice cut through the classroom air:

"Aiden Wells."

The room seemed to narrow around him.

Rosalie Hale stood in the doorway, golden hair perfectly framed, amber eyes glinting with unreadable precision. Haley froze mid-breath, her confidence faltering. Aiden turned slowly, wary but intrigued.

"That's me," he said, carefully measured.

"Rosalie Hale. We're in French together. Miss Hoff's project is due soon. For the sake of the grade…" Her lips curved in a faint, deliberate smile. "Je préfère parler français."

(I prefer to speak French.)

Aiden straightened, surprised but unfazed. "Pas de problème. Quand veux-tu commencer ?"

(No problem. When do you want to start?)

Rosalie tilted her head, evaluating him like a blade sliding over marble. "Après les cours. Peut-être au café en bas de la rue ?"

(After school. Maybe the café down the street?)

Aiden shook his head lightly, a faint smirk forming. "Trop bruyant. La bibliothèque est mieux. Moins de distractions."

(Too noisy. The library's better. Fewer distractions.)

Her amber eyes flickered with a subtle surprise. Most people followed her lead without question. Aiden did not.

"Alors, tu n'aimes pas les distractions ?"

(So, you don't like distractions?)

"Seulement quand elles sont utiles."

(Only when they're useful.)

Haley's heart stuttered in her chest. She had walked into the classroom with purpose and bravado. And now, seeing the effortless back-and-forth, the private rhythm they shared, she felt entirely outmatched.

Rosalie leaned slightly forward, voice soft but laced with precision. "Et tu me considères comme une distraction ?"

(And do you consider me a distraction?)

"Peut-être. Mais pas une mauvaise."

(Maybe. But not a bad one.)

The words hung between them, sharp and intimate. Haley's breath caught. The smile she had practiced melted into a tight line. She felt the heat of inadequacy bloom across her chest, the contrast between herself and Rosalie unrelenting.

Rosalie's lips curved faintly. "Mlle Hoff m'a dit que tu serais un défi. J'espère qu'elle avait raison."

(Miss Hoff said you'd be a challenge. I hope she was right.)

Aiden met her gaze evenly. "Un défi, ça dépend. Tu cherches à gagner, ou juste à tester mes limites ?"

(A challenge depends. Are you trying to win, or just to test my limits?)

Her eyes flickered again, almost imperceptibly, as if assessing the measure of him.

"Peut-être les deux."

(Maybe both.)

Haley could no longer mask her discomfort. Her mouth went dry, her smile vanished. Her confidence had been swept away like dust in a storm. She watched Aiden stand steady, not intimidated, and felt the sharp, sinking realization that some things were not hers to claim.

Rosalie's smirk never faltered outwardly, but she caught Haley's subtle retreat and a fleeting pang of something she didn't recognize—envy? Amusement? She didn't care to analyze. Not now.

"Alors c'est décidé. La bibliothèque. Après les cours. Et ne sois pas en retard—je déteste attendre."

(Then it's settled. The library. After school. And don't be late—I hate waiting.)

"T'inquiète pas." Aiden's voice remained calm. "Je suis toujours à l'heure."

(Don't worry. I'm never late.)

He let her leave, heels clicking sharply against the tile, perfect as ever. But inside, Rosalie felt the faintest stir, a slight unease threading through her calm. The trace of him lingered, burning in memory, and she found herself needing a moment alone.

[A few moment later]

The hallway emptied enough for her to slip into the girls' bathroom. She shut the door with a muted thud. Her reflection stared back at her, flawless as always. Golden hair, flawless skin, amber eyes… yet her pulse felt unsteady.

Her hands gripped the sink lightly, knuckles paling. She inhaled, exhaled, counted a slow rhythm, but it was useless.

His presence lingered in her mind, the scent, the confidence, the way he had matched her in French, note for note. Years of restraint and control, honed among humans who never matched her, seemed suddenly fragile.

The warm light of the bathroom reflected in her eyes, but all she could see was the subtle tightening of her chest, the slow thrum of something dangerous and electric. She had kept herself composed for decades, and yet here, in the quiet, she felt the edges of her control fraying.

She leaned closer to her reflection, studying the lines of her face, lips pressed tight. Control. The word felt brittle, like it might shatter if she thought too hard.

Her body hummed with something she hadn't allowed herself in years, subtle, restrained, psychological more than physical, but insistent, nonetheless. She could feel the temptation, the challenge, even the faint draw of desire tangled with admiration and curiosity.

The mirror offered no comfort, only the reminder that this feeling was new, unfamiliar, and dangerous. She pressed her palms harder against the sink, straightened her shoulders, and whispered to herself: Not now. Not him. Control.

Yet, even as she left the bathroom, her composure outwardly intact, a thought lingered, almost hidden: if Aiden Wells truly proved dangerous… she wasn't sure she would resist him.

[At The Same Time]

Haley walked to class, head lowered, trying to breathe evenly. Her steps felt heavy, her braid bouncing unevenly with every stride. She tried to swallow her feelings, to mask the ache of being outshone, but every glance at her own reflection in the hallway mirrors reminded her of the stark contrast.

By the time she reached her seat, she had plastered a smile on her face, laughed at jokes she barely heard, and feigned distraction. No one noticed, but inside, Haley felt the hollow echo of defeat, the warmth of hope she had walked in with had burned away, leaving only the bitter taste of envy.

Even as the teacher began the lesson, Haley's thoughts lingered on the rhythm of Aiden's voice in French, the subtle exchange of glances with Rosalie, and the knowledge that something profound had passed between them, something she would never reach.

Aiden walked in the hallway, the chatter of students and the clatter of lockers forming a dull background hum. He tugged his backpack higher on his shoulder and allowed himself a quiet exhale.

He thought about Rosalie, the way she had leaned forward, amber eyes sharp and amused, yet somehow soft at the edges. Every word had been deliberate, every phrase a gentle challenge. A challenge… maybe both, he mused, recalling her French reply. She had tested him, and he had met her stride for stride, smiling inwardly at her audacity.

Then there was Haley, standing too close, a little too eager, the braids of her hair falling like loose armor she tried to wield as confidence. Her offer to attend the party had been transparent, thinly veiled behind a casual shrug. He had chuckled quietly to himself, shaking his head as he replayed her bright grin. She wanted something, and it wasn't subtle. He knew what she really wanted, attention, validation, maybe a fleeting taste of control, and he wasn't interested. Not like that. He had let her words slide, his tone polite but firm, his mind already elsewhere.

The corners of his mouth tugged upward at the memory of her disappointment, but the thought didn't linger long. His mind was elsewhere, already chasing the ghost of Rosalie's smirk, the way her words had carried both playfulness and precision, the subtle pull of her presence that made the world shift slightly on its axis.

He could feel it, even now, a quiet stirring in his chest, like a low vibration threading through the calm monotony of the school day. That pull was more than curiosity, it was a tether, invisible yet tangible, pulling him forward toward the afternoon, toward the library, toward the chance to see whether the teasing warmth behind her amber eyes would blossom into something heavier, something more.

Aiden chuckled softly again, shaking his head at himself. He had no illusions—he wasn't infatuated, not yet, but the thought of Rosalie out of the classroom, closer in space and time, made his pulse tick just a little faster. He felt a faint smile tug at his lips, one that had nothing to do with Haley or anyone else in the hallway, and everything to do with the challenge of her.

And yet, beneath the amusement and the anticipation, a quiet question lingered. What might happen after school?

The thought wasn't urgent, it wasn't panic, but it hovered in the back of his mind, a soft hum of possibility. Every step he took carried a subtle rhythm, like a countdown toward the moment he would see her again, sit across from her, and exchange the careful play of words and glances that had already begun to define the tension between them.

For a moment, the hallway felt less crowded, less chaotic. He imagined the library, quiet, cool, the faint scent of books mingling with the lingering aroma of cookies he had baked. He imagined Rosalie leaning forward again, her voice soft but precise, the faint trace of her presence pressing gently against his awareness. He imagined… possibilities.

And he allowed himself a private chuckle, brushing the hair from his eyes as he navigated the throng of students. Haley had tried, but he had seen straight through her. Rosalie, however… she was a puzzle he wanted to explore, carefully, deliberately, with a patience he rarely afforded anyone.

As he moved toward his next class, he couldn't help the quiet thrill winding through him, the sense that the ordinary world might fracture just enough after school to make space for something extraordinary.

More Chapters